The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Tiggernits]

does This trade even have a possiblity of being fair i really think it dosent,but i would like to know for sure

I would say it's very unfair to you, are there even any list pets in there?

[ostrich]

[X]

Fair? Demand wise AND rarity wise, please! Thank you so much!

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

[X]

Fair? Thank you so much! :-)

unfair to you ^^
The green dog is an 08 very rare
The other is from 08 but is worth a mid-late 09 rare due to an extended release

[Mythic]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jJKfoWm9Ug

Is this a fair swap? Demand wise too?

Ah! Thank you

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42784020&userid=30130&signature=3Yio6Fz73J-tjJKfoWm9Ug

Is this a fair swap?

unfair to them as theirs is from 09 c:

[kaplantai]

is this fair for purple heart husky?
boop

[*Nevi Nova*]

i belive this is unfair to me,but to be sure http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KeT7Cv3f1Q :3

[Rangiku]

Ok so I need a few opinions here. I sent a trade to someone who was trading items they had more then one of. I found they had one of the dog plushie items I needed from the advent calender. I added it in and went to my items and added the blue coco mug from a different batch in the advent calender.

Original trade

They came back and edited it to this:

And added in a LOT of old items

Considering they were asking for old Easter Eggs and Animal Eggs from '09 and '10, I wasn't keen on trading them. Not to mention, I wasn't really sure how fair the trade was. Also, I was just really only asking for a swap.

So I edited it back to the original trade:

With the Advent Plushie and Coco Mug

And the person cancelled the trade claiming the trade was unfair. Seriously, they are both from the Advent Calender. I am wondering, was the original trade unfair in anyway, or the edited trade where all the eggs and items were added in?

I'd say the 1st was perfectly fair.

Kinda figured as much. Though what's the opinion on the second trade? The one which was edited.

[dudevinci]

Help?I know that they are overpaying but i dont knoww!!

[SayonaraBye]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hFWeoTOY4w