The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[clm]

Also, are ghosts(candy) really worth x2 as much as the other candy? I thought they all had same rarity.

the ghost candys are half as likely to be given than a lollipop, or a candycorn

the shop has taken the ghost candy rarity into account - if you look at it, you need about half as many ghosts as you do candycorns or lollipops in order to buy the stuff in there

Worth twice as much though? I guess it depends on if you are buying a lot of ghost costumes... lol

Sorry, can't help with trades, just wanted to drop off that tidbit

[MusicEmily]

I was wondering if I could get a few opinions on this

Them: July 08 Sunback Dog

Me:

Aug. Yellow Sorbet
Aug. Gearback Tribal
Sept. Blue Rose Dog
Sept. Red X Tritail
Sept. Target Tri-tail
Sept Blue Panda Rat
Black Sept 08 Rat
Sept. Light Leopard
Oct. Teal heavy Stripe
Oct. Red Light Stripes
Oct. Bi-Eye
Oct. Nick Cake Dog
Oct. Jaguar Rat
Advent Santa Hat Cat
Snowflake Advent (the rare one with one snowflake not the commons)
Gray 2nd Gen Parent w/ Green Eyes Advent Dog
Angel Advent
Advent Horse
Black Advent
Gray 2nd Gen Parent w/ Blue Eyes Advent Dog
Fox Advent Cat
Both Advent Lions
Jan. God Robot Dog
V-Day Lion
Growing V-Day Malk Dog
St. Patty's Day Dog
Both April Fool's Cats
Red Grinner
Red Sorbet Bun
BMD Bun
2 Common Bunnies
Yellow Bunny
Red Butter Bun
Hyena Bunny
Dogtag Bunny
Tribal Bunny
Heart Bunny
2 June Dark Pink Shima B-Wolves (the rare ones)
2 Rare Bumblebee Spiders
Red Panda PPS
June Wood Angel
June Dark Wood Dog
2 Gray Shima PPS
Ice PPS
Evil PPS
Buckskin Pony PPS
Moonflight KISS PPS
Aug. 09 Green B-wolf
Rainbow Horse (the rare rainbow maned one, not a draft horse)
Sept 09 Rainbow Mosiac Horse
Jade PPS
Black Betta

And 50+ retired/C$ items and possibly 3-4 Halloween Specials (not the dragons or pumpkins, the ones you get with candy) and possibly some C$

Is that offering too much? I'm not sure, I know there are a lot of rares in that offer...sorry it's so long btw XD

-Chianya

good god that is waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too much

[Carm]

I was wondering if I could get a few opinions on this

Them: July 08 Sunback Dog

Me:

Aug. Yellow Sorbet
Aug. Gearback Tribal
Sept. Blue Rose Dog
Sept. Red X Tritail
Sept. Target Tri-tail
Sept Blue Panda Rat
Black Sept 08 Rat
Sept. Light Leopard
Oct. Teal heavy Stripe
Oct. Red Light Stripes
Oct. Bi-Eye
Oct. Nick Cake Dog
Oct. Jaguar Rat
Advent Santa Hat Cat
Snowflake Advent (the rare one with one snowflake not the commons)
Gray 2nd Gen Parent w/ Green Eyes Advent Dog
Angel Advent
Advent Horse
Black Advent
Gray 2nd Gen Parent w/ Blue Eyes Advent Dog
Fox Advent Cat
Both Advent Lions
Jan. God Robot Dog
V-Day Lion
Growing V-Day Malk Dog
St. Patty's Day Dog
Both April Fool's Cats
Red Grinner
Red Sorbet Bun
BMD Bun
2 Common Bunnies
Yellow Bunny
Red Butter Bun
Hyena Bunny
Dogtag Bunny
Tribal Bunny
Heart Bunny
2 June Dark Pink Shima B-Wolves (the rare ones)
2 Rare Bumblebee Spiders
Red Panda PPS
June Wood Angel
June Dark Wood Dog
2 Gray Shima PPS
Ice PPS
Evil PPS
Buckskin Pony PPS
Moonflight KISS PPS
Aug. 09 Green B-wolf
Rainbow Horse (the rare rainbow maned one, not a draft horse)
Sept 09 Rainbow Mosiac Horse
Jade PPS
Black Betta

And 50+ retired/C$ items and possibly 3-4 Halloween Specials (not the dragons or pumpkins, the ones you get with candy) and possibly some C$

Is that offering too much? I'm not sure, I know there are a lot of rares in that offer...sorry it's so long btw XD

-Chianya

Over offer on your part!

[Chianya]

Okay, I thought so XD I kept trying to make it an auto accept but this trade has dragged on for a week or two now and I'm a little tired, I'm going to remove some pets and send them an official oncer and for all cancel or accept this trade lmao Any tips on what I should remove?

-Chianya

[MusicEmily]

everything except the augusts and septembers, then it's up to you but I'd take 2 or 3 more out too.

[Chianya]

Thans Good, I could use several of the other pets in other trades lol **clutches Rainbow horse** That I'm keeping for myself though XD Thanks guys! ^_^

[Seasonal]

Is this fair?
My:

4 candies

Their: Witch costume
Ghostie

I thought it kind of seemed unfair that they were only getting the pet and candies, considering the candies are pretty easy to find right now...

[Carm]

Is this fair?
My:

4 candies

Their: Witch costume
Ghostie

I thought it kind of seemed unfair that they were only getting the pet and candies, considering the candies are pretty easy to find right now...

The candies do have a limit (I believe) so maybe fair.

[Chianya]

Is this fair?
My:

4 candies

Their: Witch costume
Ghostie

I thought it kind of seemed unfair that they were only getting the pet and candies, considering the candies are pretty easy to find right now...

The candies do have a limit (I believe) so maybe fair.

Yeah, the candies do have a limit in hunting, but you can trade for however many you like I'm going on the "every man for himself" way of thought and trading pretty much whatever for candies, so I've traded up to common Oct. 08s for like 4 candycorns, but I'd say that's a....fairish trade since the witches costume goes for C$20

-Chianya

[Carm]

My rainbow horse for their Tess wood-winged dog? I don't think it's fair..