The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Lilo.]

Need some help with these two!
one two

[madisong]

Need some help with these two!
one two

the first is pretty unfair to you c:
both liontails go for around 2 nons on their own while the patchwork and marionette go for around 1!

I’m the second trade so I’d love some opinions!

[myth;]

Need some help with these two!
one two

the first is pretty unfair to you c:
both liontails go for around 2 nons on their own while the patchwork and marionette go for around 1!

I’m the second trade so I’d love some opinions!

Agreed, that first trade is madness. Your's are much older and more valuable, their value will go up faster than the 2010 stores.

The second trade they're over, drink me gets 2 to 4 nons, maybe more. The bee is worth 2, Strawberry 1 or 2, clockwork 1. So those are overpay alone, the rest is a very nice add as the dragon cat has amazing demand. It's a really good trade, though unfair to them by demand.

[elleminnowpee]

Is this trade fair?

6 2010 Rares for my 1 2009 Very Rare

My gut says its a decent trade, but I'd like to hear that from someone else.
Thanks in advance for the help.

[Niragi]

Need some help with these two!
one two

If you still go by the old (outdated) list values, in the first trade each liontail is able to fetch around 2 nons right now due to demand and the fact that they’re older more valuable store pets, the other side goes for 1 non per pet, so you’d be overpaying with 2 nons or one liontail~

The second trade seems like overpay on their side to me, usually the drink me is able to get around the worth of 4 nons, the strawberry goes for 1.5 nons, the clockwork bun for 1 non and the ur bee for 2 nons so these three pets would already add up to 4.5 nons. If you include the demand of the dragoncat pps, the ex-tier 7 and ex-tier 5 dogs too their side adds up to about 5ish nons including the demand of quantity~

However demand is up to you and what you personally value each pet at ^^

[--------------]

More trades lol
Should I do this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81321359&userid=559606&signature=Sax8cJkhFb3fqr1P-FVoqw

Well Unfair to you! the dragon horse is re-released and original release was 2009. well. 2009 pet worths 2018 store pet.

well. i'm not good at detecting fair or unfair

[Ashara]

Is this trade fair?

6 2010 Rares for my 1 2009 Very Rare

My gut says its a decent trade, but I'd like to hear that from someone else.
Thanks in advance for the help.

Your dog has very high demand, I traded one for a 2012 store pet a few days ago. Had many offers of multiple 09 rare and very rares before that so I wouldn't take this.

[myth;]

More trades lol
Should I do this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81321359&userid=559606&signature=Sax8cJkhFb3fqr1P-FVoqw

Well Unfair to you! the dragon horse is re-released and original release was 2009. well. 2009 pet worths 2018 store pet.

well. i'm not good at detecting fair or unfair

Don't know = don't answer

That Halloween Sleipnir is a tier 1 advent, 3 or 4 09 rares, but demand wise it can get much more. The store pets on your side are worth more because they are rarer, harder to find, and have excellent demand. If I were you, I'd trade the llamas alone (or 2 of them, maybe 3 depending on how you value them), they trade for 2 09 rares each and match the sleip's demand.

[RiN_X04]

hello! ever since the retirement of the list, i'm not really sure how list trades go.
(though even before i wasn't the best)
i know some people still follow it and some people don't.
this doesn't look fair to me. how much should be added?

[Sazzy-Shanghai]

Hi, I'm really bad at trading items for pets, I know the Turkey set is from Thanksgiving 2010, but am unsure of ist worth. trades/viewtrade.php?id=81320303&userid=394592&signature=Xv8nKaFrl7c9RQiTt1mwKQ