The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[.crossfire.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93596077&userid=345128&signature=Lp9g1iD0IcVgs29e5q8fWQ
fair? Is the demand for Tallstar this high?
Thanks!

this is fair since a 2014 store pet typically goes for a low advent (3-6 '09 rares)
the warrior is worth 2-3 '09 rares, however the robot cat store pets can easily fetch 4-5 in my opinion. It is up to you what you would like to do. All warriors tend to have the same value (unless it was a very rare warrior from 2008. as they can easily fetch an ma)

[kiro,,]

Thoughts?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93574934&userid=768234&signature=ERPPEAt8osJh7zZwiPfJCw

they are way over. everywhere i checked the speckled rat was listed at 0.25-0.5 nons, while the august pps is listed to be worth 0.25 nons (with demand). so everything other than the rat is over, and the rat is borderline over as well.

Including demand, would this be fair to me?

Another opinion?

theyre over by about 95 c$

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93596077&userid=345128&signature=Lp9g1iD0IcVgs29e5q8fWQ
fair? Is the demand for Tallstar this high?
Thanks!

its borderline fair, though they could be under by like an '09 rare depending on how much you value the warrior. the robo cat is worth a low advent/3-4 '09 rares, while the warrior can go for 2-3 '09 rares with demand

[Sheelah]

would this be ok?? I'm not sure, since mine are from the store
Thanks for any help!

and another one

The first one is unfair in my opinion, because your side is worth 13C$ and their side is worth 3 2018 uncommons = 3-6 C$

The second trade is 13 C$ on your side and their side adds up to 10-20 C$, I would say it depends on how much you value a 2018 uc in C$

I'd actually like a second opinion on the bottom trade. The first one only has 3 items and is worth more and all the extra items amount to not much more? This isn't making much sense to me. I want to make the trade fair for the both of us. Thank you for any help.

P.S. Both ribbons and the doggo, as well as the Earth, Metal, Water, Fire and wood are from CNY 2018 < the same year as the 3 items from the above trade. Reason why I'm questioning this.
The other plushies are from 2019-Rat, Tiger, Snake , Horse, Goat, Monkey, Rooster and Dog.

[dillydallydarlene]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93596413&userid=47800&signature=RFkFsVyonIuNCycJRrQ1OQ

How fair is this? Should I add more?

[Sunlordess]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93596532&userid=305844&signature=_zjibwyTRILlvYVz4Vj_Kg

How fair is this? Honestly not the most interested in any of these pets so I'll probably cancel anyways. I'm still not sure about trading lingo either so I don't know what a "non" is or anything. Mainly need help figuring out this lion's worth because I've had a few people want to trade for him.

Edit: just got another trade for him:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93596560&userid=305844&signature=O2wmNi2LmJnMfcQl3L-FTQ

[Se5nsucht]

Help, please?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93596529&userid=980667&signature=SJC_pl5G38vPo7uwzRzoaw

[kiro,,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93596532&userid=305844&signature=_zjibwyTRILlvYVz4Vj_Kg

How fair is this? Honestly not the most interested in any of these pets so I'll probably cancel anyways. I'm still not sure about trading lingo either so I don't know what a "non" is or anything. Mainly need help figuring out this lion's worth because I've had a few people want to trade for him.

VERY unfair to you. those are all regular rares, while your lion was very high up on a (now discontinued) list of very valuable pets. the lion is worth 2 'nons' which is about 170 '09 rares. their side is less than 2.5 '09 rares

[Thovatos]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93596532&userid=305844&signature=_zjibwyTRILlvYVz4Vj_Kg

How fair is this? Honestly not the most interested in any of these pets so I'll probably cancel anyways. I'm still not sure about trading lingo either so I don't know what a "non" is or anything. Mainly need help figuring out this lion's worth because I've had a few people want to trade for him.

Based on successful trades, the UR Lion seems to be valued between 1.5-2 nons with the pet falling on both ends of the value range depending on trading users

So anywhere from 1.5-2 non dogs, the lion's worth.

A lot of pets can add up to a non's worth, so explaining the lion's value is a bit hard.

1 non =10-12 MA's (mid advents)
so 1.5-2 x 2= 15-22 MA's (Mid advents.

1 MA=7-8 09 rares(? i'm pretty sure this is the number)

so 7-8 09 rares per ma on a 15-22= roughly 105-176 09 rares.

Please correct me if my math is off, but by lemming terms, they are way off, lol~

[Sunlordess]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93596532&userid=305844&signature=_zjibwyTRILlvYVz4Vj_Kg

How fair is this? Honestly not the most interested in any of these pets so I'll probably cancel anyways. I'm still not sure about trading lingo either so I don't know what a "non" is or anything. Mainly need help figuring out this lion's worth because I've had a few people want to trade for him.

Based on successful trades, the UR Lion seems to be valued between 1.5-2 nons with the pet falling on both ends of the value range depending on trading users

So anywhere from 1.5-2 non dogs, the lion's worth.

A lot of pets can add up to a non's worth, so explaining the lion's value is a bit hard.

1 non =10-12 MA's (mid advents)
so 1.5-2 x 2= 15-22 MA's (Mid advents.

1 MA=7-8 09 rares(? i'm pretty sure this is the number)

so 7-8 09 rares per ma on a 15-22= roughly 105-176 09 rares.

Please correct me if my math is off, but by lemming terms, they are way off, lol~

Oh my goodness... so many number haha. Well thank you and Kiro for explaining this to me

[Sheelah]

would this be ok?? I'm not sure, since mine are from the store
Thanks for any help!

and another one

The first one is unfair in my opinion, because your side is worth 13C$ and their side is worth 3 2018 uncommons = 3-6 C$

The second trade is 13 C$ on your side and their side adds up to 10-20 C$, I would say it depends on how much you value a 2018 uc in C$

I'd actually like a second opinion on the bottom trade. The first one only has 3 items and is worth more and all the extra items amount to not much more? This isn't making much sense to me. I want to make the trade fair for the both of us. Thank you for any help.

P.S. Both ribbons and the doggo, as well as the Earth, Metal, Water, Fire and wood are from CNY 2018 < the same year as the 3 items from the above trade. Reason why I'm questioning this.
The other plushies are from 2019-Rat, Tiger, Snake , Horse, Goat, Monkey, Rooster and Dog