The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[faygopup]

hello! discord said these were a bit over but wanted opinions here :3

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111352584&userid=1034135&signature=YoOHrAfVn__avX8BRkLUXA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111351730&userid=1034135&signature=KCqLzo1qYA7StudnzS89Hg

[MothsGraveyard]

Is this a fair trade? Im not very well versed on list pets, not even sure if this is onehttps://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111355847&userid=929056&signature=PxwS9z1C36vG_BQEiu8mGg

[oceanz]

I need help with this trade & this one please c:

[Crazyclaww]

This is unfair, right?
or is this dog special in a certain way?

EDIT: thank you !!

[Happily Wrathful]

This is unfair, right?
or is this dog special in a certain way?

heya! the dog is from April fools this year! i dont know what its rarity will be but im quite sure you can get him for far less.

Is this a fair trade? Im not very well versed on list pets, not even sure if this is onehttps://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111355847&userid=929056&signature=PxwS9z1C36vG_BQEiu8mGg

hello! thats not a list pet, your banner pet is worth much more than that and has high demand alone so i would NOT accept this trade. im not entirely sure what the centipede banner pet trades for so i would suggest finding that out before trading it away.

hello! discord said these were a bit over but wanted opinions here :3

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111352584&userid=1034135&signature=YoOHrAfVn__avX8BRkLUXA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111351730&userid=1034135&signature=KCqLzo1qYA7StudnzS89Hg

the first one was actually quite unfair to you zodiacs are worth .5 MA or 5 old rares
the store pets alone dont make up for that as they are worth only 1 old rare. they are popular but they are in the store right now so i honestly would NOT trade them for anything above an old rare at most.
then adding on 15c$ make it even more unfair

on the second i believe that is maybe overpay on your side by just a bit but you will most certainly have a much better time trading away the store.

I need help with this trade & this one please c:

howdy
trade one;
at minimum all of your store together are worth 14 old rares but with demand on the fairy foxes i would value them at their most which is 17 old rares
their side only adds up to 6 old rares max.

trade two;
your side is 20 old rares 2MA
their side; 6 old rares
the lions may have some demand enough to make them worth 3 old rares but even then its only 8 old rares

neither trades are fair to you

[holoville]

still need a little bit of help ,,, i haven't done a trade on cs this big
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111355297&userid=1106748&signature=0Hon0nid7cT_OdDDi7wOfg

[Happily Wrathful]

still need a little bit of help ,,, i haven't done a trade on cs this big
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111355297&userid=1106748&signature=0Hon0nid7cT_OdDDi7wOfg

heya! the pets you have are all still growing and so value is spotty, if you really would like the dogs they are offering i would say this is a relatively fair trade for them however personally i wouldnt trade any growing dogs unless i have doubles of them.

[livviecakes]

i'm no good with trading store pets so is this fair?

trade here

[Jained]

Help Pleaaaaaaaase

[TooSpooky]

is this fair? Thanks

got this bid too

just got this new bid, is it fair? Thanks