The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Akatsuki]

1
2
3
4

Which of these are fair? im so loving the BMD

[Opalide]

1
2
3
4

Which of these are fair? im so loving the BMD

First trade is wrong link - the trade with the UR cucumber is overpay to them, but the cucumber is a pain in the butt to trade. Other two are unfair to you.
I strongly suggest you put this pet in a locked group, and do not trade it until you understand it's value and worth.

[Phroggy]

I'm not too good with items, were these fair or did I overpay?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78974732&userid=261596&signature=EZsAEP1doBdAONrvgzr_Lw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78975220&userid=261596&signature=g9f4PmlfZ3eWIoyNI_BI2g

[Mykie]

Is this okay? I thought it was but im not good with lists ://

[scythe.]

Is this okay? I thought it was but im not good with lists ://

the cake dog is a tier 8 September pet worth 6 mid advents, whereas as best I can figure your side is worth about 4 mid-advents and a low advent. There is something to be said for quantity and how it tends to be valued more than raw quality but ultimately that’s up to the person you’re trading with and how they value it.

Hope this helps! c:

[Birdie.]

Could I get help on making this trade fair, please :> !

[Horsesrule5000]

Fair? Thank you.

[Mykie]

Is this okay? I thought it was but im not good with lists ://

the cake dog is a tier 8 September pet worth 6 mid advents, whereas as best I can figure your side is worth about 4 mid-advents and a low advent. There is something to be said for quantity and how it tends to be valued more than raw quality but ultimately that’s up to the person you’re trading with and how they value it.

Hope this helps! c:

Thank you!

[coastie_cowgirl]

I've been asking for like a week now, please help!

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Help please! Have two offers and trying to decide which is better - Which would you take, and why?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78952615&userid=40385&signature=HXYJYwTK017J7lO-Aba7nQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78960796&userid=40385&signature=kRLu-3PpFa7gKrcAhTRXjw

[ordinary people]

Are any of these fair and which one you would personally accept? Thanks c:

One
Two
Three