The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[Crazychick3000]

Is this trade fair? If not, how could it be made fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24254820&userid=1540&signature=vvgKldo6mX7EUvPyn5AZ9w

Very very unfair to the rats as they are on the Main List.

[Soccerplayer48]

Is this trade fair? If not, how could it be made fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24254820&userid=1540&signature=vvgKldo6mX7EUvPyn5AZ9w

Very very unfair to the rats as they are on the Main List.

Agreed, in no way is that even close to faor

[Alva.]

So I just got this trade earlier today, and I'm so conflicted D:

They offered this:

2011-10-30
Rare

2012-05-23
Rare


And they wanted this in return:

2009-12-21
Rare

Neither of the pets are of the same year, however they are both of the same rarity and there are two of them. Plus the item, which I'm not well educated in the rarity and trading of them.

I'm really confused on whether or not I should accept, and if I need to edit, what should I give back? Thanks for any advice, it's very much appreciated.

[Windveil]

Okay, if it's not fair what should the person with the dog add? I really want to get rid of my rat DX

[montyboy101]

Fair?

[Nebulava]

Are one of these fair? I'm unsure

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24253970&userid=363746&signature=wnaUYLfImPsLgR9bNpNmvg

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24255289&userid=363746&signature=KNclhfPBpsmuOnMgg1o_2w

[Riverotterr]

Is this fair? Thanks!

[Soccerplayer48]

Are one of these fair? I'm unsure

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24253970&userid=363746&signature=wnaUYLfImPsLgR9bNpNmvg

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24255289&userid=363746&signature=KNclhfPBpsmuOnMgg1o_2w

Second one is unfair to you!

[Fat Unicorn]

Is this fair? Thanks!

Fair, the white scarf dog is being moved down. ^_^

[Nebulava]

Is this offer fair? They say its overpay, but I have a hard time believing that