The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Macklin584]

Which is better for my UR flowerpot?
A GWJ
Or 1,200 c$?

[sæter]

Would a trade like this be fair? Thank you in advance for your help! ^^

angel advent = 7 mid advents

cake dog = 6 mid advents
grinner = 2 mid advents

unfair to them by a mid advent.

Personally, demand wise I wouldn't take it. For the Angel I've been offered a low main before (despite the main having bad demand) and higher sept. list pets. Also, the grinner on their side is known to have 'bad demand' so you most likely won't trade it off for its actual value.

demand wise, i disagree in a few ways; all these pets tend to go for their worth, if not the angel fetching a bit of overpay. regardless, overpay is provided here (by a mid advent). to expect in-demand low mainlists or higher septembers for the angel advent simply because some have paid that much in the past is unfair; not many people who know the list would be willing to overpay that heavily.

i have owned two grinners, and within 2 days of getting them, i traded them both off fairly. they may not have good demand, but they don't have bad demand. getting their full value isn't difficult if you trade the right people.

considering these factors, i personally would take it. it's also quantity/a trade down, which has value of its own. there's really no harm since it's overpay.

[vlksx]

Someone offered me a trade up but I’m hesitant as they wanted most of my rares..
trade

haven't got any answers yet :')

[.Wolfskralle.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73696642&userid=163939&signature=b4qgOd55UK210CSBAPIcog
Is this a good offer?
I'm not too good at item rarities.
Thank you!

[WesternWolf2528]

Would a trade like this be fair? Thank you in advance for your help! ^^

angel advent = 7 mid advents

cake dog = 6 mid advents
grinner = 2 mid advents

unfair to them by a mid advent.

demand wise, i disagree in a few ways; all these pets tend to go for their worth, if not the angel fetching a bit of overpay. regardless, overpay is provided here (by a mid advent). to expect in-demand low mainlists or higher septembers for the angel advent simply because some have paid that much in the past is unfair; not many people who know the list would be willing to overpay that heavily.

i have owned two grinners, and within 2 days of getting them, i traded them both off fairly. they may not have good demand, but they don't have bad demand. getting their full value isn't difficult if you trade the right people.

considering these factors, i personally would take it. it's also quantity/a trade down, which has value of its own. there's really no harm since it's overpay.

I understand where you're coming from. I'm just speaking from personal experience as I've had trouble trading off the grinner, sometimes cakes dogs too, but that's probably me just not finding the right person/getting bad luck. But with what you've said, it sounds like a good trade.

[sæter]

I understand where you're coming from. I'm just speaking from personal experience as I've had trouble trading off the grinner, sometimes cakes dogs too, but that's probably me just not finding the right person/getting bad luck. But with what you've said, it sounds like a good trade.

of course; i understand your perspective. in the case of the cake dog though-- generally, pets that have higher worths and have mediocre demand can struggle to be traded off, but this applies to all pets. i personally got a fair trade for mine, but it did take a bit of patience. a lot of trading is about finding the right people; there'll always be someone willing to take a fair enough trade. ^^

[Ethy]

I'm not sure if I should accept this or not?
I would love some help, thank you in advance to anyone who responds <3.

[velocity,,]

thoughts?

[lil rascal]

Hello! Can I please get some opinions on:
This trade - I have no idea what red cerbs go for these days
And this trade? - I have no idea what the UR BW is currently going for either, plus their side has good quantity.
All help is appreciated!

Edit: this as well - from memory the moonswirl is worth 4 nons but I'm not sure how much it typically goes for, since I don't think it goes for 4 nons. Thanks!

Alright, so. The first trade; with the red cerb, is pretty good. Red cerb goes for 3 nons. So i'd say it's about fair.
Second trade; with the BW, I don't know what the BW is worth, but I'd say the other 2 trades are better.
And the last trade; with the Moonswirl, Moonswirl is worth 4 nons, but it tends to go for underpay.

Honestly I'd say you should pick either first or last one from these 3, but I'd wait for more offers.

Thank you!
Any other opinions?

With the first trade I disagree, demand wise most people I've seen value the Red Cerb at 1-2 nons at most (yes there might be a few outliner trades of dogtags or such but they're rare not the norm). So whether it's a good trade or not depends on where you value the Raven & Joker demand wise.

Second trade demand wise the BW usually goes for 1-1.5 nons, though could get more if you're patient. With the other pets I'd say this is a good offer.

Third trade the Moonswirl can apparently be hard to trade down fairly (haven't had one myself but most really high list pets are hard to trade down fairly just due to their high value), I've seen people value it around 3 nons when they want a quick trade off but you might be able to get the full 4 nons worth if you're patient. Personally I think this is a good offer if you're looking to trade up

[pigeon -]

how does this trade look? Valuing the bmd around a balloon dog?
I know quantity is quite sought after c: