The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[RPG]

Can someone please help with the Totoro plushie?
Trader says it's worth at least 1 MA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97655463&userid=932354&signature=3Gb_A8k9yMWeJX95YbNhRw

Most recent value I saw is a late 09 rare. It's most definitely not worth an MA, they are probably trying to scam you.

actually, according to gay's items popular worth guide spreadsheet, the totoro plushie can get 1 ma (the way its written out implies that its not worth anything more, but feel free to get another opinion from item traders). so i personally do agree that this person is asking for more than its worth in this trade, but the information that you linked is from 2019-2020 x so its no longer reliable to use as a guide ^_^

[PlagueNBlight]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97674370&userid=994990&signature=0F2zty4hrhfq32uwULXwyA

I still need help with this trade, thank you in advance! ^^

[Lex.]

Can I please have help with these trades and whether they are fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97678801&userid=725458&signature=8Jim7fNi-WyPPhqtu9KWBg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97676273&userid=725458&signature=Airx_yC-D2UMT_XcEU_itQ

Thanks,
Happy New Year everyone.

By rarity 2011 stores go for 2-4 MA's, but since it's a horse it'll be less demand. Emerald BWolf goes for 1 MA
The buns have no special value if I'm correct and neither does the draft
Very unfair to your green sorbet

350c$ is about 1 MA, and the rares really dont add much value, and add 1.3 MA's to the trade
unfair to your green sorbet

[fluffyme]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97679093&userid=569082&signature=pM_fhTxzEvxwOF5tg0rnOQ

Would this trade be fair?

[lextopia]

hi there,
opinions on these bids for my cheetah pps?
one
two
three
four
any help is appreciated, thanks in advance<3

second opinions if i weren't to take the 1st bid?

thoughts on this trade?

[Lex.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97679093&userid=569082&signature=pM_fhTxzEvxwOF5tg0rnOQ

Would this trade be fair?

2019 stores can get a 2010 rare each
your store might be able to get a 09 rare
2 2010 Rares = 1 09 Rare
The uncommon doesn't really make a difference, so the rest is dependent on how you value your fox store pet

[Fallenleaf]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97681977&userid=867789&signature=ClXQrybeOumMS70zR9UGQQ
Another trade, but for a TD Cinnabon.

[Demonking Urizen]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97679093&userid=569082&signature=pM_fhTxzEvxwOF5tg0rnOQ

Would this trade be fair?

2019 stores can get a 2010 rare each
your store might be able to get a 09 rare
2 2010 Rares = 1 09 Rare
The uncommon doesn't really make a difference, so the rest is dependent on how you value your fox store pet

“Can get a 09 rare”? 2017 store pets are worth 100% a mid 09 rare without including demand of certain ones.
The fairy foxes have proven to get 2 09 rares with ease

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97681977&userid=867789&signature=ClXQrybeOumMS70zR9UGQQ
Another trade, but for a TD Cinnabon.

Unfair to them
The td Cinnabun seems to get 2n, as the Kirin itself gets 2n as well.
The 0.5n of the two Skele pps aren’t necessary
(Yes, contrary to some people’s opinion Skele pps are too common to get 0.5n as true dates)

[Expresso.]

is this fiar? thanks

[Demonking Urizen]

is this fiar? thanks

Unfair to you by a lot
Your side is worth 1.5 ma + 2 09 rares (= 15 09 rares) as the Blue-eyed gsd can get 1 ma with ease and the Phoenix dog gets 0.5 ma
While their side is only 4-5 09 rares