The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Lothlórien]

Is this a good trade?
View Trade Here (Trade 1)
I heard that the Pink Sept. List Dogs can be hard to trade off because they don't have good demand. Is that true? Will the fact that it's a re-release make it's demand even worse? It's REALLY hard for me to get List Pets so I'm super picky with trades involving them. I would love some help with this please.
Thanks in advance.

Edit
Can I also have help with this one?
Click Me! (Trade 2)

[velocity,,]

thoughts?

[vlksx]

Someone offered me a trade up but I’m hesitant as they wanted most of my rares..
trade

[velocity,,]

thoughts?

[PenguinQueen]

How does this offer look?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73745064&userid=613649&signature=NbCCAClLSaMF97LP2K0d5w
I like the shima but how fair is this demand wise? Would you personally accept?
Any opinions would be greatly appreciated, thank you c:

[WesternWolf2528]

Hello! Can I please get some opinions on:
This trade - I have no idea what red cerbs go for these days
And this trade? - I have no idea what the UR BW is currently going for either, plus their side has good quantity.

All help is appreciated!

Edit: this as well - from memory the moonswirl is worth 4 nons but I'm not sure how much it typically goes for, since I don't think it goes for 4 nons. Thanks!

[rainfall;]

how fair is this to the other person?

[*~Heart Of Hearts~*]

How fair is this? Does the apple have good demand compared to the rat? Thanks in advance!

[WesternWolf2528]

How fair is this? Does the apple have good demand compared to the rat? Thanks in advance!

Rarity wise unfair to the rat as it is 1 tier higher, demand wise is debatable depending on who you trade. The apple has poor demand just like the rat but you'll be more likely to trade off the apple compared to the rat. From my personal experience, I'd keep the apple instead.

[MercyRez]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73748500&userid=929548&signature=zxjh6ytuRcuU2LpjcS2sPw