The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[karsdarling]

Need some help with this one. Second opinions are cool! Thanks, loves. ^^

Still seeking help~

[lady gaga]

Hi i'm running an auction for my Store pets and I was wondering how I should rate this Bid Please keep rarity and demand in mind!

I wouldn't take it, cake dogs have terrible demand, cannot go for fair trades, and these (since there's a lot of them) store pets can go for a lot more! (cuz they have high demand XD)

I'm on the other side, could I have some other opinions? Thank you!

[KkSpecial]

I know that this trade --> HERE <-- is unfair to me (thank you to those who helped)!

Would removing all the uncommons and replacing them with a '17 store pet (VR) be a fair trade?
Or no, because the dog is an '09 extended release into '10?

A 2017 store pet is only worth a late 2010 rare, so that would still be unfair to you.

Thank you.

If I kept all the uncommons and added a '17 store pet (VR) would that make it a bit more fair?
Basically would the uncommons even out the month gap between the early '10 rare to the late '10 rare?

[A.skater.Chen]

How's a grey malk dragon (September) for the wolf PPS (main) because I know that malk dragons can go for quite a bit with demand, so what side, and what would they need to add to make it fair?? Thank you soooooo much for any help!!!!!!!!!

[Mysterious~]

How's a grey malk dragon (September) for the wolf PPS (main) because I know that malk dragons can go for quite a bit with demand, so what side, and what would they need to add to make it fair?? Thank you soooooo much for any help!!!!!!!!!

I'd personally take it! The dragon has great demand and is a tier higher!!

[A.skater.Chen]

How's a grey malk dragon (September) for the wolf PPS (main) because I know that malk dragons can go for quite a bit with demand, so what side, and what would they need to add to make it fair?? Thank you soooooo much for any help!!!!!!!!!

I'd personally take it! The dragon has great demand and is a tier higher!!

Thanks so much!! Second opinions?? im not sure what you mean by it's a tier higher, the dragons a September and the wolf pps is a main, I'm just curious:) thanks so much tho!!!!!

[justina valentine]

Is a patchwork dog fair for my green toxic?

I'm on other side x

[Mysterious~]

How's a grey malk dragon (September) for the wolf PPS (main) because I know that malk dragons can go for quite a bit with demand, so what side, and what would they need to add to make it fair?? Thank you soooooo much for any help!!!!!!!!!

I'd personally take it! The dragon has great demand and is a tier higher!!

Thanks so much!! Second opinions?? im not sure what you mean by it's a tier higher, the dragons a September and the wolf pps is a main, I'm just curious:) thanks so much tho!!!!!

Oops sooo sorry, I thought you said PPS Malk dragon, what's with my reading lately, I need to check my eyes anyways, nah I wouldn't! Maybe get them to add atleast the Malk dragon doesn't add to the wolf PPS even with demand, maybe ask them to add

[ruel]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1P8XI4763A

Is this fair?

[Autvmn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dbDkarjT8Q

Is this fair? (: thanks!