The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Inara Serra]

is this fair?
and if not, what trade would be fair?

[kayyye]

is this fair?
*bulk trade*

this too please ♡

[cherri ♥︎]

hey!
is this bid fair?
if not how would you rate it and how much more do you think i can get?

[ScuroFenice]

Could I get an opinion on this trade please? I searched the C$ worth thread for each of these and came up with: 50 for the warrior cat, 45 for the gold robot dog and 32 for the pony.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87525244&userid=247513&signature=PWAY23IDJaOR2GbTubKGKw

They sent a trade back explaining that:

the cat is a warrior cat, and a rare is worth 45 from 09 , a vr is 2 09's and warrior cats demand double the value, the gold doggo is worth way more than 45 and the vr pony id do 54 lowest

Could someone help me out and let me know which info is correct please? I do admit the posts I looked at, some were from one year ago but there were some posts from this January. How much does C$ worth change in one year?

They did cancel it but I would still like to know if the trade I sent was fair or not.

Personally I use "Pet value in C$" to determine prices. however, its outdated and not updated here so prices are not accurate in my opinion.

So, a 09 rare/VR would be valued between 45-55c$.

Now, the dice point have okay demand and 35-45 and potentially in the 50s would be fair. It's an 09 VR.

The robot dog I have seen alot of people with them listed at about 65+, yet I've never seen one go for that much. Its again an 09 VR, but because it's a desired species it could go for the 45-55 range with patience on their part maybe more.

As for the VR warrior... according to the thread a rare/VR from 08 is worth approx. 50C$. all warriors usually go for overpay. It's hard to find people who want to sell them for there value. My rare warriors from 09 easily brought 100C$ each, while my more desired 09 rare warriors (scourge for example) brought 115.

The warrior you offered on is VR whitestorm from 2008. Mine, which I held an auction for a few months ago- brought 150.
"this trade"

But again, the value in C$ thread i use hasnt been updated since 2017. So the prices on there arent accurate and I personally, add an extra 5C$ for each year.

Okay, thank you for the opinion

[honeylavendersoap]

Is this fair? If not, how many 2011 uncommons would need to be added or what needs to be added on either sides? trades/viewtrade.php?id=87525104&userid=990573&signature=tFMPVHtJJY5Q6XgiEbeQ_g

[.always.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87520026&userid=630538&signature=tWWagbdfh08rXzTBtMKEMA
I really love my dog, but I don't know about the fairness demand wise. Could anybody help me? Thank you!

[Angelhearth]

Is this fair?
Trade includes items and rares

[Mouse 13]

I'm looking to trade this group for a Ur Phoenix. How much more would I need to add? Or am I getting close to the value?

[VashTheStampede]

Got another I need an opinion on, please?

[Inara Serra]

is this fair?
and if not, what trade would be fair?