The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Maplefrost]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5046750&userid=146804&signature=QnQ6xuk71hJBP9Wr7EUcZA

This is unfair, right?

Not fair to 08 Green Bat dog. It's in higher demand than the 10s , plus there is an age difference.

[Diabolic]

Side 1: Both UR dogs

Side 2: Purple Toxic

UNfair to the UR dogs.

How about:

Side 1: Both UR dogs.

Side 2: Purple Toxic, Target Dog, and 09' Okapi PPS

Purple tox still needs to add, at least another good september, and possibly some
09 rares or an advent 08 or two.
Both the UR dogs are worth a common-ish august VR by themselves so...

[Niko]

Whose bid is the best? I'm having the worst time choosing! I'm auctioning my White July pup.
Bidder #1- CE Galaxy pup+Dogtag Bunny+Blue & Orange 08 dog+ 1 Pock
Bidder #2- CE Galaxy pup+08 Pink Rerelease+Blue & Orange 08 Bobtail Dog+180 C$
Bidder #3- BMD+Red Rose+Dogtag Bunny+08 Advent pup+Malk Foal+500 C$
Please answer ASAP! I don't want to give names out, so I called them Bidder #1, ect.

[bostonbruins33]

for

and


unfair to the horse side, right?

[Rachel Amber]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5044754

Fair or not? If not, which side needs to add?

[Maplefrost]

for

and


unfair to the horse side, right?

Yup. Really unfair to horse side.

[alana]

Would this be fair? I really suck at sorting out rarities like this.


for

I think its unfair to the UR Cat, but I'm not sure. What would need to be added to make it fair? Or is it fair? Thanks!

Could I have maybe one more opinion? Thanks!

[average]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=4965435&userid=594&signature=3esL4BVzWTCoVplWIxiXrQ ?


---

Blue and green sorbets for BE Galaxy?

[Bakura]

Is This Fair?? The dog is a non-tag, the sorbet is still unknown, the galaxy is cleareyed and the coon is still unknown

[Maplefrost]

Would this be fair? I really suck at sorting out rarities like this.


for

I think its unfair to the UR Cat, but I'm not sure. What would need to be added to make it fair? Or is it fair? Thanks!

Could I have maybe one more opinion? Thanks!

I think its fair, but get a 2nd opinion.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5044754

Fair or not? If not, which side needs to add?

Can't see it. "Share trade."

Is This Fair?? The dog is a non-tag, the sorbet is still unknown, the galaxy is cleareyed and the coon is still unknown

For UR B-wolf?