The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Zigzagoon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70356028&userid=857986&signature=ljXm3aJvvLQP2gjhr9Eblw

Is this fair? I was sent it and they said it was fair but I do t think it is

Very unfair to you. The rat on your side is on the mainlist. The dog on their side would be fair for only one of those cats.

[Silverstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70356028&userid=857986&signature=ljXm3aJvvLQP2gjhr9Eblw

Is this fair? I was sent it and they said it was fair but I do t think it is

unfair to you. The rat is a main list pet (speckled rat) and overpay alone ^^!

[dragonstars]

This fair or over?

[beastly.]

This fair or over?

overpay on the balloon dog's side by quite a bit. the balloon dog is on the mainlist, while the bunny is on the september list and, as a bunny, has bad demand anyway. the balloon dog is worth 3 blue roses, and the bunny is only on the same tier as a red rose (four tiers below the blue rose). pink balloon is worth 505 c$ and the bunny is only worth 220C$ so they are off by another 200 about. the spider is irrelevant, it's just a normal very rare.

[Topsy Turvey]

This fair or over?

overpay on the balloon dog's side by quite a bit. the balloon dog is on the mainlist, while the bunny is on the september list and, as a bunny, has bad demand anyway. the balloon dog is worth 3 blue roses, and the bunny is only on the same tier as a red rose (four tiers below the blue rose). pink balloon is worth 505 c$ and the bunny is only worth 220C$ so they are off by another 200 about. the spider is irrelevant, it's just a normal very rare.

The spider is known as the Bumblebee Spider and is on the first tier of the Advent List, so not quite what I was class as irrelevant c;

[beastly.]

This fair or over?

overpay on the balloon dog's side by quite a bit. the balloon dog is on the mainlist, while the bunny is on the september list and, as a bunny, has bad demand anyway. the balloon dog is worth 3 blue roses, and the bunny is only on the same tier as a red rose (four tiers below the blue rose). pink balloon is worth 505 c$ and the bunny is only worth 220C$ so they are off by another 200 about. the spider is irrelevant, it's just a normal very rare.

The spider is known as the Bumblebee Spider and is on the first tier of the Advent List c:

oh whoops, didn't see it for some reason. still very unfair to the balloon dog i'm afraid.

EDIT: that in consideration, the spider is 3-4 '09 rares. since the bunny is a red rose, even if you were to be generous and count it as a blue rose, they would still need to add 112 '09 rares. (blue rose is worth 7 mid-advents, mid-advents are 7-8 '09 rares each, so 7*8 is 56 and times two since it's another two blue roses is 112.) again, that would still be generous since the bunny is not on the level of a blue rose, though maybe the C$ bridges that gap.

no matter how you cut it, pretty unfair to the balloon.

[miilk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70356028&userid=857986&signature=ljXm3aJvvLQP2gjhr9Eblw

Is this fair? I was sent it and they said it was fair but I do t think it is

No it’s wayyy over on your side. The rainbow dog doesn’t equal the mainlist rat!

[TzatzikiTheLeg]

Is the demand just that bad,or did I underpay?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70361111&userid=896398&signature=3XKOSyyh3gHrk4_XN7vSLA

[boodles]

Is the demand just that bad,or did I underpay?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70361111&userid=896398&signature=3XKOSyyh3gHrk4_XN7vSLA

They overpayed a lot... the demand only lowers its value a couple tiers. You barely offered an Advent list pet.

[TzatzikiTheLeg]

Is the demand just that bad,or did I underpay?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70361111&userid=896398&signature=3XKOSyyh3gHrk4_XN7vSLA

They overpayed a lot... the demand only lowers its value a couple tiers. You barely offered an Advent list pet.

That's what I thought,thanks for the help!