The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Voxezi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HScq95l_ZA
and
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HWsHX0obTg
?
If they are both fair, which one is better?

[asta,]

VR '08 Bat Dog
For
Green Sorbet or Red Toxic

[~Lost Firefly~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5184194&userid=132615&signature=VqYttEr2r3MXpBEfPpgtLA

answer me quick, please!!!

[Atomic Blue]

What should I add to this?
08 advent tinsel tess horse
for
UR, red or green butterbun/any VR bunny?

For UR Butterbunny, that's a complete no. It's a rip off for the bunny. The tinsel horse sounds ok with the bwolf butterbunnies, like teal or red. Maybe you'd have to add more, not entirely sure.

New thread. Yay.

There was no point in celebrating no bad advice, if there's bad advice just correct them. No big deal.

[Seasonal]

VR '08 Bat Dog
For
Green Sorbet or Red Toxic

The Bat Dog is only worth a September '08. So, unfair to the Red Toxic or Green Sorbet.

[Allizia]

VR '08 Bat Dog
For
Green Sorbet or Red Toxic

Um, maybe unfair for the sorbet, and same with toxic.
Thats my opinion, at least

[kivr & fireflii]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5184194&userid=132615&signature=VqYttEr2r3MXpBEfPpgtLA

answer me quick, please!!!

Unfair to top

[iBrevity]

VR '08 Bat Dog
For
Green Sorbet or Red Toxic

I'd say definitely unfair to the bottom side.
Get a second opinion though. c:

edit- ninja'd xD

[Kaya]

VR '08 Bat Dog
For
Green Sorbet or Red Toxic

Really unfair to bottom side, on both counts.

[asta,]

Thanks all.