The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[asdfghj61]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6hlo9FweGg

thank you for helping, very nice of you

[lucky333123]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33630657&userid=347616&signature=UlBTiJWyDmaZ6hlo9FweGg

thank you for helping, very nice of you

Very very unfair to the bwolf. That bwolf is on the main list.

[Nebulava]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33630657&userid=347616&signature=UlBTiJWyDmaZ6hlo9FweGg

thank you for helping, very nice of you

That trade is out of this world o.o Good choice accepting, the Lion isn't even on the Rares List. Never regret that decision.

[Patch.]

Is this fair? Thanks c:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DoVR2d7yNw

Fair if not slightly unfair to the top but please get a second opinion

Is a bottom tier advent worth 3 09 rares or more than that?

Around 2-3 mix '09 rares approx.

1) Disagreed. Pocky's only worth a 2009/2008 rare.
2) It's 3 2009 rares.

[The Black Cat]

Is this trade fair? The other side doesn't mind a slight overpay, by the way. Any opinions?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fLh5pi6GsA

Some help, please? Thanks

Please help me, I have answers saying it's unfair to me and then also answers saying it's unfair to them. Can someone tell me exactly what needs to be added/removed on either side? Thank you My mouse cursor is literally on the accept button but I need one last opinion, I will give an uncommon pet to whoever gives me a decent answer. As in, the answer that leads me to decide if I want the trade or not. I really do, but I need one more answer to confirm.
Which leads me to the question, how many '09 rares is a January '09 VR actually worth?

Also another trade I got, what needs to be added to their side to make it fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BCEv7WjGRg

I've asked like a million times but I really need an answer on the top one, and I'd also like some advice on the bottom one. Both traders are starting to get slightly impatient...

[woofdogz]

fair? thank you!

[Nebulava]

fair? thank you!

I'd say it's about fair, but I'd suggest a second opinion^^

[Pinkapillar]

Ur pot + other rares and very rares= ur bee?

[Patch.]

Ur pot + other rares and very rares= ur bee?

This is up to you and your partner to decide, since the new URs don't have a range.

[lucky333123]

Is this fair? Thanks c:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DoVR2d7yNw

Fair if not slightly unfair to the top but please get a second opinion

Is a bottom tier advent worth 3 09 rares or more than that?

Around 2-3 mix '09 rares approx.

1) Disagreed. Pocky's only worth a 2009/2008 rare.
2) It's 3 2009 rares.

1) The pocky is worth a Oct/Nov '08 R/VR viewtopic.php?f=20&t=559754&start=880

2) I said a mix since it varies on species, etc.

Ur pot + other rares and very rares= ur bee?

We can't give you an accurate answer since the UR Bee is one of the newest UR and is going all over the list right from a low main to a high main.