The "is this a fair trade?" thread [notice 2nd post]

[Ashki]

UR DOG+???= Red toxic?

Red x PPS. ^^

[Patch.]

Don't two Balloon dogs equal a Yellow/Green Toxic?

Yep but there's the 09 UR dog gap in there too. And a rose PPS would be unfair to the red toxic.

Oh, geez. I was looking at the UR Dog's tier instead of the Red Toxic's. My apologizes. ^^;

[Ghoul (gone)]

What do they need to add to their side? Thanks! <3

[resque]

(This is the same trade that Moonstiel posted, I'm just explaining the circumstances)

Is this fair, and if so, is it worth autoing an auction over the next highest bid, which is this?

I checked the "how much is this item worth" thread, and it says that the halo in the first trade is worth a septembers list, I wanted to make sure that this was still true and that there is a demand for it.

Thanks in advance,
Myth

I would say it's a better offer than the 2nd bid. :3 And yes, it is still worth a low September. According to Solloby's item guide, and her new draft, it is worth a low September. I'm not sure how good its demand is, but old/rare items tend to have a lot of demand. c: I'm not too sure there are a lot of people willing to pay that price for the 08' halo though.

[Mommyof3]

i know this is unfair to me, i asked a couple of different people and one told me the balloon bunny was worth 6 '09 rares and the dog was worth 7 '09 rares, i looked through what the person who was offering had and i dont know what to input on their side to make it fair, do i add wishlist pets or ....???

here is the trade link-
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NMK6k1sFmg

[lucky333123]

I usually don't have trouble with trades or at least not that often anymore but I'm not sure what to add/remove to make this trade fair to both of us. I already know that it is unfair to me. Please don't take the demand of the cloud dog into account since the demand will pretty much disappear in a week or so.:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nZFh3Bc4MQ

Thanks for the help!

I would say they need to add an early 10 rare or so.

Thanks, would that be on top of the '11 rare they have on their side? If I removed the '11 rare, should something else be added?

[Miladux]

i know this is unfair to me, i asked a couple of different people and one told me the balloon bunny was worth 6 '09 rares and the dog was worth 7 '09 rares, i looked through what the person who was offering had and i dont know what to input on their side to make it fair, do i add wishlist pets or ....???

here is the trade link-
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NMK6k1sFmg

Add some 09 rares at least ten, try 14 and say to them its fair. Your gray husky is near the top of ther advent list along with bunny :3

_Bluecollie

[Kyar]

I usually don't have trouble with trades or at least not that often anymore but I'm not sure what to add/remove to make this trade fair to both of us. I already know that it is unfair to me. Please don't take the demand of the cloud dog into account since the demand will pretty much disappear in a week or so.:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nZFh3Bc4MQ

Thanks for the help!

I would say they need to add an early 10 rare or so. :)

Thanks, would that be on top of the '11 rare they have on their side? If I removed the '11 rare, should something else be added?

Yeah if you took it off I would say another late 09 rare instead of the 10. :)

[Mommyof3]

i know this is unfair to me, i asked a couple of different people and one told me the balloon bunny was worth 6 '09 rares and the dog was worth 7 '09 rares, i looked through what the person who was offering had and i dont know what to input on their side to make it fair, do i add wishlist pets or ....???

here is the trade link-
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NMK6k1sFmg

Add some 09 rares at least ten, try 14 and say to them its fair. Your gray husky is near the top of ther advent list along with bunny :3

_Bluecollie

ok thank you i will try that..this is my first time trading pets from any of the 3 major list lol

[lucky333123]

[quote"lucky333123"]I usually don't have trouble with trades or at least not that often anymore but I'm not sure what to add/remove to make this trade fair to both of us. I already know that it is unfair to me. Please don't take the demand of the cloud dog into account since the demand will pretty much disappear in a week or so.:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nZFh3Bc4MQ

Thanks for the help!

I would say they need to add an early 10 rare or so. [/quote

Thanks, would that be on top of the '11 rare they have on their side? If I removed the '11 rare, should something else be added?

Yeah if you took it off I would say another late 09 rare instead of the 10.

Thanks!