The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Bebop]

Would this be fair?

Edit; oh yay, first post!

I don't think so, that's a store item right? Worth more than a brand new cat and free items.

[Umbrellas]

This groupfor a Raven Dog :
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=367101 ?

I don't think so yet, what else could I add to make it fair?

Unfair to the raven.
If we were to exclude demand; you'd need to have about 8-10 mid '09 rares. This is excluding demand.

8-10 is way too much. That would be enough for a high advent.
You'd probably need about 5 mid '09 rares.

[typewriter,]

This groupfor a Raven Dog :
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=367101 ?

I don't think so yet, what else could I add to make it fair?

Unfair to the raven.
If we were to exclude demand; you'd need to have about 8-10 mid '09 rares. This is excluding demand.

8-10 is way too much. That would be enough for a high advent.
You'd probably need about 5 mid '09 rares.

It takes roughly four mid '09 rares to get on the advent list, then the gap between tiers is about an '09 mid rare.

[Halsin]

Which is fairer:
x
x
x

[Veja]

Is this fair?
Some of the pets they are offering I either don't want or already have one of, so I'm not really sure at this point.

Would this be a fair swap for a Raven dog?
If not, what should be added, and to what side?

[daz]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance:3


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Z49S-FxyUQ

looks unfair to you:)

agreed

VERY unfair. they need to offer WAY more than that

[Thranduil's Elk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ujF7GACZ3w
Second opinion please? (first was on other thread)

[Umbrellas]

It takes roughly four mid '09 rares to get on the advent list, then the gap between tiers is about an '09 mid rare.

Please read DaDwarf's post about this here.

[strudelcat]

This groupfor a Raven Dog :
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=367101 ?

I don't think so yet, what else could I add to make it fair?

Unfair to the raven.
If we were to exclude demand; you'd need to have about 8-10 mid '09 rares. This is excluding demand.

8-10 is way too much. That would be enough for a high advent.
You'd probably need about 5 mid '09 rares.

But considering the demand of some of the higher advent pets,
such as a BA, you would need to pay way much more. so 8-10 09 mid
or a month or two higher would be appropriate for some of the high value high advent pets.

[deer;;]

Would this be fair?

Edit; oh yay, first post!

I don't think so, that's a store item right? Worth more than a brand new cat and free items.

Okay, thank you! c: