The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[owlcoholik]

Is a gearback tribal worth a line tribal?

Gearback is a tiny bit rarer, but it's a pretty fair trade.

[Dawulf]

Someone wants my Pink Moon '08 for their Heavy Stripe Orange 'o8 (both Octobers).

I want to save the Pink to help get one of the "Final 5" (see Sig). What would be the wise thing to do? I think the Heavy Stripes are more common but I am not sure...?

[bainwolf5]

Hello! I was just wondering:

It seems like most people didnt get a blue roan for this months pet, andI got 3. I've already traded one away, but can someone tell me if a blue roan for a PPS AUg. Dog (With the side stripe-thing), is a good trade? (Taking into consderation that the blu roan is not full-staged yet, but te rarity kinda makes up for it.)

As said on pg 194, anybody know? ^^

[Kohaku]

Hello! I was just wondering:

It seems like most people didnt get a blue roan for this months pet, andI got 3. I've already traded one away, but can someone tell me if a blue roan for a PPS AUg. Dog (With the side stripe-thing), is a good trade? (Taking into consderation that the blu roan is not full-staged yet, but te rarity kinda makes up for it.)

As said on pg 194, anybody know? ^^

I don't think that's a good trade, as the august PPS is very rare and the the blue roan is just rare, and from this month. but if someone offers you that than definitely take it

[Dawulf]

Hello! I was just wondering:

It seems like most people didnt get a blue roan for this months pet, andI got 3. I've already traded one away, but can someone tell me if a blue roan for a PPS AUg. Dog (With the side stripe-thing), is a good trade? (Taking into consderation that the blu roan is not full-staged yet, but te rarity kinda makes up for it.)

As said on pg 194, anybody know? ^^

Is it the smiling one or the grumpy one?
I would accept it personally if either. The frowning one (or dark blue/black one) is crazy rare, and the light blue/white grinning one is rare too.

[~Sakura~]

i have another question about my pink baloon auction offers:

which one seems better?

-Holly Warrior Christmas 08 Cat and a Red Rose Dog + September 08 Lepoard Dark spotted dog +three-tailed X dog and moonswirl bunny

or

-Dark Pink Butterfly Wolf, The Malk Rare two striped Spider, Rare Green August Butterfly Wolf, Blue Roan Pony, Rainbow Mosiac Horse, Yellow PPS Mosiac Horse, PPS Buckskin Pony, Yellow PPS Dice Pony.


thanks for any help!

[LostHope]

I would say the first seems a bit better in my opinion

[Dawulf]

i have another question about my pink baloon auction offers:

which one seems better?

-Holly Warrior Christmas 08 Cat and a Red Rose Dog + September 08 Lepoard Dark spotted dog +three-tailed X dog and moonswirl bunny

or

-Dark Pink Butterfly Wolf, The Malk Rare two striped Spider, Rare Green August Butterfly Wolf, Blue Roan Pony, Rainbow Mosiac Horse, Yellow PPS Mosiac Horse, PPS Buckskin Pony, Yellow PPS Dice Pony.


thanks for any help!

Holly Christmas '08 Cat? Hollypaw was not released in December.... or is it the Fox cat?

[Celestial]

i have another question about my pink baloon auction offers:

which one seems better?

-Holly Warrior Christmas 08 Cat and a Red Rose Dog + September 08 Lepoard Dark spotted dog +three-tailed X dog and moonswirl bunny

or

-Dark Pink Butterfly Wolf, The Malk Rare two striped Spider, Rare Green August Butterfly Wolf, Blue Roan Pony, Rainbow Mosiac Horse, Yellow PPS Mosiac Horse, PPS Buckskin Pony, Yellow PPS Dice Pony.


thanks for any help!

Holly Christmas '08 Cat? Hollypaw was not released in December.... or is it the Fox cat?

Yes, she means the fox cat. Some people call him the holly cat :]

[Minimanta]

Yes, holly as in the plant-berry-thing she have in her mouth^^ Very common christmas decoration plant. (Or whatever hollys are XD Not sure if it's a plant, tree or flower. But well it dosen't matter here^^ )

And I would say the first offer is best. Yes there are a couple of rare 09 pets in the last one but number 1 are just better in my opinion. A lot of the horses aren't that rare.