The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[p e a c h y]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42767099&userid=598743&signature=uUI2eAebWV29Os80nNnPLQ

Is this fair? any help is nice c:

[ExDream]

Fair demand wise?

Also what about this?

2nd looks like a overpay to me for the dragon. They give you 3 Sep Listies and 4 Advent Listies. There are 6 malk dragons and only 3 of them are Sep List. So there's a chance that the egg could become a non-list pet if I'm not wrong.

Need a second opinion on this. I'm the one offering the Red Toxic c:

[Pandorah]

Just a quick list beginner question:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42765864&userid=345128&signature=wXigiOqrumq1y0tHe7Y14A?

Fair?

Thanks!

[Kyar]

I'll accept it but I'm pretty sure it is an overpay, are White Feb really worth so much these days? (Ignore the Yellow Sorbet, it's a date swap :3)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZgjFkTorcA
Thank you ^__^

It's quite unfair to them. :) The pets on their side (ignoring the sorbet) are worth a bit more than a mid advent. :)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42766502&userid=673874&signature=bxksVzhOEGbZsNwdGfs5fw

Is this fair? If not what can I / them take away or add?

Unfair to them. Your store pet is worth an early '10 rare. Their '10 rare black cat would be a fair trade.

Thank you!! May I have a second?

Agreed - the black cat alone is enough. :)

Hello! Could someone help me? Is still store pet worth 09 rare or something similar or not?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42765094&userid=16640&signature=EGq-5PN_-Pc0t_6HuB42Nw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42765993&userid=16640&signature=IbEsB1T9FKbwpiZUHFuanA

They're each worth about a mid 10 rare. The first trade is fair but the second is a bit unfair to you. :)

[*]
Could I have some opinions on this, please? c:
(The bun on their side is a re-release from 11'.)

It's a fair swap consitering how the bunny is an 11 rare and you have a 10 uc. Demand wise I'd say no because most people want those fennec foxes. But I'm not sure if demand went down after their layout changed. Plus I don't know the real date for the bunny (as in month and day) please get another opinion

Alright, thank you!
Can I get a second opinion, please? c:

In terms of rarity it's probably slightly unfair to them but it's hard to say exactly what the demand of the foxes are with the new lines. I haven't been following them much. I'd say it looks fine if you want to do it though - it's not glaringly unfair anyway. :)

[DerbyGirl]

is this a fairtrade? thank you very much

Until we know which outcome it becomes, it is impossible to give an accurate answer. If it's a rainbow mane, unfair to you-and if not very unfair to them. You should know by tonight depending what time you adopted the horse.

[ExDream]

Fair demand wise?

Also what about this?

2nd looks like a overpay to me for the dragon. They give you 3 Sep Listies and 4 Advent Listies. There are 6 malk dragons and only 3 of them are Sep List. So there's a chance that the egg could become a non-list pet if I'm not wrong.

Need a second opinion on this. I'm the one offering the Red Toxic c:

[K9.]

Hello what would make this fairer to them? Basically what do I need to add?

Thank you in advance!

[p e a c h y]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42767099&userid=598743&signature=uUI2eAebWV29Os80nNnPLQ

Is this fair? any help is nice c:

[jinbad]

Alright, thank you!
Can I get a second opinion, please? c:

In terms of rarity it's probably slightly unfair to them but it's hard to say exactly what the demand of the foxes are with the new lines. I haven't been following them much. I'd say it looks fine if you want to do it though - it's not glaringly unfair anyway.

Okay, thank you Kyar! c:

[Kyar]

Fair demand wise?

Also what about this?

2nd looks like a overpay to me for the dragon. They give you 3 Sep Listies and 4 Advent Listies. There are 6 malk dragons and only 3 of them are Sep List. So there's a chance that the egg could become a non-list pet if I'm not wrong.

Need a second opinion on this. I'm the one offering the Red Toxic c:

Do you know what the outcome of the dragon will be? I haven't been following the eggs lol. And you're just wondering about the red tox trade?