The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[justina valentine]

[quote=Ophidi"]

is this fair?
Thanks to whoever helps <3

I’d say unfair to you because of the Shima Longtail. If it was removed from the trade and replaced with some extra ‘09 Rares, I believe it would be fairer. I’d get a second opinion, though The Shima and Blue Dragon PPS both have very good demand.

Thank you, could I get another opinion?[/quote]
Unfair to the top rarity wise.

Demand wise.

I wouldn't remove the Shima, it has high demand and can sometimes go for mainlists, if you value the dragon at a sorbet like most do i'd remove a cake dog as with quantity and demand people would easily trade a sorbet for the 09 staff set plus some small add.

It's up to you, I haven't seen the shima get a mainlist in a while and have been offered one for about 7 old items which = to about a tier 7 advent.
What do you value your set at? Most people won't pay a list for one 09 staff pet unless (mutant or shima) unless it's as a set. This is defiantly a good trade if you are looking to work up the list.

[Ironic Equation]

What about this one? I'm extremely tempted since I like the white lolita, but I also like the pets on my side. What does a punk set tend to go for?

[Lucids]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78971931&userid=950275&signature=Jx8XJxe6BmUUCyr3CPmq9Q

Is this fair?

[Astellia]

I'm hosting an auction and these are the bids so far. I just need some second opinions. Which one seems the most fair? I like bids 5, 6, & 9.

1
2
3
4
5
67
8
9
10

Auction ends tomorrow and I REALLY need advice.

[skybristle]

Bid 1
Bid 2
Personally, I think NEITHER of these are fair. From bid two I have the store dog and for bid 1 the store griffyn. Help?

[Opalide]

Could I grab some opinions on this?
I believe that set was a free set from last year.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78972270&userid=613269&signature=-rJ7MVZvAbJkwlHzrq1Lng

[Eagle's Eye]

Bid 1
Bid 2
Personally, I think NEITHER of these are fair. From bid two I have the store dog and for bid 1 the store griffyn. Help?

Your advent tier 5=6-7 '09 rares
The first offer is worth roughly 2 '09 rares. Unfair to you.
The second offer is worth 4.5 '09 rares while your side is worth 7-8 '09 rares. Unfair to you.

[skybristle]

Bid 1
Bid 2
Personally, I think NEITHER of these are fair. From bid two I have the store dog and for bid 1 the store griffyn. Help?

Your advent tier 5=6-7 '09 rares
The first offer is worth roughly 2 '09 rares. Unfair to you.
The second offer is worth 4.5 '09 rares while your side is worth 7-8 '09 rares. Unfair to you.

Just as I thought! More opinions?

[justina valentine]

Bid 1
Bid 2
Personally, I think NEITHER of these are fair. From bid two I have the store dog and for bid 1 the store griffyn. Help?

Your advent tier 5=6-7 '09 rares
The first offer is worth roughly 2 '09 rares. Unfair to you.
The second offer is worth 4.5 '09 rares while your side is worth 7-8 '09 rares. Unfair to you.

Just as I thought! More opinions?

I agree with Eagle

[skybristle]

Bid 1
Bid 2
Personally, I think NEITHER of these are fair. From bid two I have the store dog and for bid 1 the store griffyn. Help?

Your advent tier 5=6-7 '09 rares
The first offer is worth roughly 2 '09 rares. Unfair to you.
The second offer is worth 4.5 '09 rares while your side is worth 7-8 '09 rares. Unfair to you.

Just as I thought! More opinions?

I just got this bid, is it fair? Even if it is, I don't like the pets much.