The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Zelda the Wolf]

hi i need help, im having an auction of 24 zodiacs (2 complete sets) and this is one of the bids i got. is it fair demand wise?? i know a full set of zodiacs goes for a low to mid september list but im not sure how much 2 sets go for.

also i already have an marionette so idk if i want another one lol. thank you for any help!

the marionette goes for a sorbet I believe. I personally got a cakedog for 1 set of zodiac and though I was doing well. I would instantly accept a marionette for 2 sets in my opinion.

ok second opinion? ive auctioned full sets of zodiacs 3 other times and i've gotten mainlists each time for only one set. this is 2 sets so i was kinda expecting more.

also whats the joker buns value with demand? someone is offering me that for my 24 zodiacs as well.
does the joker bun go for fair trades or underpay/overpay?

zodiac sets go for a high sept at most. the nette goes for a sorbet or more depending on trader. i would accept.

[September Rain]

How does this bid on my auction look?

[Katsumi-Luna]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68745979&userid=26641&signature=eRe0K9QX5xl_4NHTAM0wOA

Would you guys accept?

[iconerfatty]

UGRENT! please help! <3 consider demand

Unfair to them, your side is only worth a mid september list and the rat is on the main list. Demand depends how low you value the rat & how you feel about trading up

Definetely agree, personally though, I wouldn't accept because I like your pets better than the rat

thank you, second opinion?
also need help with this. consider demand too!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lNwPrwCvEA

[Katsumi-Luna]

How does this bid on my auction look?

Very unfair to the advent

[ShimmerUnicorn]

Hellooo!
I really like both of these trades, which one is more fair for my kitsune mask dog both rarity and demand wise??
1
2
Any help would be amazing, thanks!

[September Rain]

How does this bid on my auction look?

Very unfair to the advent

Thank you! Second opinion? I know my pet is worth about 3 - 4 '09 rares.
EDIT: And this?

[.Ginger.]

Would this be fair? What would I need to add or take away?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ja21ceLIwQ

Thank you!

Still haven't gotten any opinions <3

[.soundwaves.]

How does this bid on my auction look?

Very unfair to the advent

Thank you! Second opinion? I know my pet is worth about 3 - 4 '09 rares.
EDIT: And this?

Agreed!

[September Rain]

Very unfair to the advent

Thank you! Second opinion? I know my pet is worth about 3 - 4 '09 rares.

Agreed!

Thank you! EDIT: And these two?