The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Fae]

Can I get some advice on this trade please? I know it is unfair, but I am unsure of what to ask to be added to make it fair

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100246676

Usually pretty good with deciding on trades but this one is a tough decision for me it doesnt really work with the 2:1 rule (although im only just putting that into use) but was wondering if all the event pets + dragons would make it worth more.

Make sure to use the “share trade” link so that we can see it. Also, I personally don’t recommend following the 2:1 rule too closely. It doesn’t work well with big gaps (it gets super out of control fast), and a lot of people don’t follow it for rares (I most commonly see 4:1 for uncommons to rares…I personally value a rare as 3-5 uncommons, depending on the pets involved). Just something to keep in mind.

[CicadaSilk]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100246676

Usually pretty good with deciding on trades but this one is a tough decision for me it doesnt really work with the 2:1 rule (although im only just putting that into use) but was wondering if all the event pets + dragons would make it worth more.

Make sure to use the “share trade” link so that we can see it. Also, I personally don’t recommend following the 2:1 rule too closely. It doesn’t work well with big gaps (it gets super out of control fast), and a lot of people don’t follow it for rares (I most commonly see 4:1 for uncommons to rares…I personally value a rare as 3-5 uncommons, depending on the pets involved). Just something to keep in mind.

ah sorry heres the new link trades/viewtrade.php?id=100246676&userid=992231&signature=c-ClJWQGXlDIYuKdYV8X9A
and i havent done it with any rares before, just uncommons/commons, but good advice to know

[LonerEevee]

Is https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100298878&userid=923222&signature=ADmucE3gN8J_zrZi1q3CiQ this fair?
I don't really do items all that much but i've heard the Pocky item is pretty rare / sought after, but at the same time, i've actively had timers up for all my tokens and idk how I feel about giving them all up for something I might not even use ^^'
TYSM in advance for any advice! ^^

[wolfrunner]

I wouldn’t. But that’s just me.

[Karcrab]

Can someone help me out with this trade? It's been awhile and i feel its unfair but would like to get advice

I do not know how i forgot to link the trade... trades/viewtrade.php?id=100282193&userid=942530&signature=XAv9pTU7WOD4tZZzddO3fA here it is

[Zigzagoon]

Haven’t traded rares in a while, just want to get a second opinion
Trade

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100246676

Usually pretty good with deciding on trades but this one is a tough decision for me it doesnt really work with the 2:1 rule (although im only just putting that into use) but was wondering if all the event pets + dragons would make it worth more.

ah sorry heres the new link trades/viewtrade.php?id=100246676&userid=992231&signature=c-ClJWQGXlDIYuKdYV8X9A
and i havent done it with any rares before, just uncommons/commons, but good advice to know

Definitely a bit unfair to you by dates. Those dragons and event pets don’t really have any special demand.

[abbie.]

can i get some advice on this trade?
thank you in advance!

[Valentinez]

I'd love some help with this trade:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100299233&userid=1000712&signature=JSQCNatOcK9U3Z7qT4vNbQ

Thanks in advance !