The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[BeeBagel]

I’m no good with items. Is this a fair trade?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100289848&userid=714043&signature=GkVL0Eql69NqC__6ThBW5g

[s a r o s]

A little help with this trade please? I'm not sure about animal egg worths. Thank you in advance!

[.:drizzl:.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100227882&userid=734361&signature=BDJkpZ8Op1d0BtAXQ_xVig

Is this trade fair? I know horses tend to be lower in demand and $CS-only trades aren't always recommended since people prefer to trade according to pet value. I would like some $CS but I'm not sure if it should be more or less.

Hello! I'm still looking for advice, would really appreciate any help

[Rbpuppy]

Thoughts? I value my BA at a non if that helps
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100024859&userid=42960&signature=6RNpzjyh6lSucCPRGeQ2-A

[musicgurl333]

Is this fair?

Unfair to you. "Official" values have the store pet as being worth 1 '09 rare. Following the "2:1 rule", their C$ isn't worth enough to make up the difference between the '10 horse and an '09 rare. Additionally, I will say that I think you could do a bit better than one '09 rare for the store pet.

[Pyca]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100227882&userid=734361&signature=BDJkpZ8Op1d0BtAXQ_xVig

Is this trade fair? I know horses tend to be lower in demand and $CS-only trades aren't always recommended since people prefer to trade according to pet value. I would like some $CS but I'm not sure if it should be more or less.

Hello! I'm still looking for advice, would really appreciate any help

Unfair I'd say. The horse is from the Rainbow Mane "litter" from August of 2009. According to this, a 2009 very rare goes for 35-55 C$. Since this litter is so old (and honestly probably has better demand than most horse litters) I'd want closer to the 55C$ mark. I'm also guessing that the bat is going to end up being uncommon.

If anyone else wants to give more advise on this trade feel free!

edit: hAnother source

[Sali]

Can I get some help with these two trades? Thank you very much! c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100271653&userid=273533&signature=-tTidC3K268yZCHsKR11yQ

&

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100271628&userid=273533&signature=cflLG96xBB9z-nwz-EeoCg

[CoffeeEX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100255034&userid=881679&signature=OSvLVod5kJmgi6JPErQ0nA

howdy! just wondering if this is fair, and if not can i know why? tyty!

Still looking for advice on this, thank you!

[CicadaSilk]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100246676

Usually pretty good with deciding on trades but this one is a tough decision for me it doesnt really work with the 2:1 rule (although im only just putting that into use) but was wondering if all the event pets + dragons would make it worth more.

[Pyca]

Can I get some help with these two trades? Thank you very much! c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100271653&userid=273533&signature=-tTidC3K268yZCHsKR11yQ

&

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100271628&userid=273533&signature=cflLG96xBB9z-nwz-EeoCg

Unfair I'd say. Animal eggs generally go for an uncommon from their year, and your animal eggs are pretty old compared to the rares they are offering. The tokens don't have any set rarity I don't think, and a lot of people value them differently. But in my opinion they aren't equal to your eggs either.

Eggs and their years:
Animal Egg 18, 2011, Animal Eggs 23, 24, & 25, 2012, Animal Egg 45, 2014

Sources:
How much is this item worth?

PPS Cocoon=1 MA
Each Kitsune=1-2 MA
Each Store Deer=0.5-1 MA
Each 2012 Fairy Goats=1 MA Each
Jackalope=1 MA
Nick Laptop=1 MA
09 Christmas Ornaments=1 09 rare each
And the 09 Pink Floppy ear, light blue christmas bobtail, 2nd gen bobtail, and teal dog both go for their true value of 2 09 rares.
=
17 ish MA or about 1.5 non

Each of these Android go for 0.5 non, totaling 1.5 non.

This would technically be fair if you value the Kitsune and the store Deer at their highest value. If you want the bulk store pets I'd go for it, but if you want to trade the Android up you might be able to get a slightly better offer I think. If anyone disagrees with my math or anything please let me know!

Sources:
PPS Cocoon
Store pets
Nick Laptop
09 Christmas Ornaments
09 VR dogs
Android