The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Faeyre]

I'm really bad at item trades so any help would be much loved <3

[Mewfle]

I got this trade and I'm tempted to accept, can I get some opinions on this?
Thank you in advance

I personally wouldn't, the most I've seen the little date swap thing be was around a september list ^^
You could trade the CEG for a non then trade it back down for TD one if you want.

-snip-

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... agE3tMOsbw

No, your bun is worth 6-7 Mixed 09 Rares + an 09 Uncommon as a tier 6 advent list pet. Their pet is only worth 2 2009 rares.
(I've been seeing a bunch of trades with this dog being offered for list pets, they might be trying to scam newer players or players unaware of their pet being a list)

Please don't give out false advice. The bun on their side is actually just a regular '10 VR from '10 Easter, and it's not a tier 6 advent list c: They other side actually overpaying c:

[Demonking Urizen]

I got this trade and I'm tempted to accept, can I get some opinions on this?
Thank you in advance

I personally wouldn't, the most I've seen the little date swap thing be was around a september list ^^
You could trade the CEG for a non then trade it back down for TD one if you want.

Little mistake: They got offered a BEG on a CEG, so list-wise it would be unfair to them, because the gap between pets is a Line Tribal + Balloon Dog.

But in fact, both Galaxies go for a Non each. So CEG for BEG would be fair enough.

[Mewfle]

I got this trade and I'm tempted to accept, can I get some opinions on this?
Thank you in advance

I personally wouldn't, the most I've seen the little date swap thing be was around a september list ^^
You could trade the CEG for a non then trade it back down for TD one if you want.

Little mistake: They got offered a BEG on a CEG, so list-wise it would be unfair to lilystar, because the gap between pets is a Line Tribal, so she would be paying a Skele PPS too much.

But in fact, both Galaxies go for a Non each. So CEG for BEG would be fair enough.

Yeah, I just referred to them because they're practically the same thing, sorry! ><

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62719157&userid=825453&signature=uQlCLgLEBWgezulfLNSrEg

I'm seeing around 16 ish midadvents on their side, while the nonballoon is worth around 33midadvents roughly
So it's unfair to you by about 17 midadvents.

[Pom d'Apee]

hello c:
so i got this trade, and what do they need to add to make it fair ?
thank you in advance ♥

[reanne]

this?

i want to know if this is fair both demand-wise and rarity-wise,thank you. [ is this a trade down or a trade up? because i don't really want a trade down atm;; ]

Unfair to you. Demand wise your side is unfair because rats have low demand and that's on the other side. ON your side you have a sitting cat that's an Advent Tier 5.

thank you <3 any other opinions?

[Ippolit]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4VckdL_KkA
Is this a good deal? Or is a rare warrior a better deal?

[Faeyre]

I'm really bad at item trades so any help would be much loved <3

[Skena]

.

Is this a fair trade? Thanks for any help

TRADE

.

The 2009 common alone is worth a 2013 rare (Assuming you're valuing it like this: 1 2009 c = 2 2010 c = 4 2011 c = 1 2011 uc = 2013 rare). So no it's unfair.

Okay thank you! ^^ Yes I really wasn't sure how much the 2009 dog is worth

[Pom d'Apee]

hello c:
so i got this trade, and what do they need to add to make it fair ?
thank you in advance ♥