The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[ScooterAJ]

I have another question XD Sorry I'm really bad at trading. I wish I could help some people with their trades, but the truth is, I honestly don't know anything about the main list pets that people are posting on here, nor some of the older pets. Here is the edited trade that someone sent over for my warriors:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gbqwY_3M6w
Thank you so much for the help, and I'm guessing this is pretty fair? Not sure at all. -Facedesk

Still looking for an opinion, but my auction doesn't end until Feb. 5th XD Take your time 0-0

[Lunamora]

Would a First Tier Advent List be a good overpay for a White February?

[The Black Cat]

Asking one last time before I push the accept or cancel button.
I'm not being pushy, I'm just looking for a final opinion.

Which side is overpaying?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8xd72QruhA

[Patch.]

I have another question XD Sorry I'm really bad at trading. I wish I could help some people with their trades, but the truth is, I honestly don't know anything about the main list pets that people are posting on here, nor some of the older pets. Here is the edited trade that someone sent over for my warriors:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gbqwY_3M6w
Thank you so much for the help, and I'm guessing this is pretty fair? Not sure at all. -Facedesk

Still looking for an opinion, but my auction doesn't end until Feb. 5th XD Take your time 0-0

Unfair to them.

Would a First Tier Advent List be a good overpay for a White February?

Well, it's overpay for the White Feb. I guess the rest depends on you and the person you're trading with.

[A Random Moustache]

How many advent list pets can get me a red rose?

[beemo]

Asking one last time before I push the accept or cancel button.
I'm not being pushy, I'm just looking for a final opinion.

Which side is overpaying?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8xd72QruhA

I would personally decline.

I would decline.. the others are weird looking animals.. plus your dog is one of the first dogs ever

As I am the other person in this trade, I would appreciate it if people would stop saying things like this.
This dog is from '09, it is not one of the first dogs ever.
And I am offering pets on their wishlist, it's also not nice to call animals "weird looking."
Think of the artists who made these pets and designed them.

If you aren't giving good advice, don't give any at all.

[Patch.]

How many advent list pets can get me a red rose?

It depends on what Advents you mean. The Red Rose is worth about five mid-Advents, I believe. :3

[gizmo,]

is this trade fair? please and thank you!

[Schofield]

is this trade fair? please and thank you!

Hey there! :3
I think they are overpaying slightly. ^^;

[ScooterAJ]

is this trade fair? please and thank you!

I would say almost equal, but I guess it would depend on the way you look at it. You might want to get another opinion