*DISCONTINUED* Rares List Guide (1 March 2019)

[odin]

I would like another rarity between rare and very rare, I agree. We put another rarity group for the common pets. There are a LOT of "rare" pets, and it would help see what ones are closer to uncommon and what ones are closer to very rare. For the most part, a rare is = to another rare, IMO (with a few exceptions, like if it was VR and went R with re-release, I'd probably not trade that for a recent rare, but if it's been rare years and doesn't look like it'll change soon, and I need the pet offered, I don't really care. lol)
Thanks for the fuller explanation.

[DaDwarf]

No problem :) I personally would love to see another rarity set merged into our current one, to deepen all the rarities. Because there's quite a gap between uncommon and common imo as well, same as VR. The difference between omg so rare and rare is just a huge gap too O:

[myth;]

We need to remember that the whole 'a 2009 rare is worth more than a 2017 rare' is just an assumption, we have no idea of knowing which rare is worth more than another since they are all rereleased every year, with the exception of store pets of course. c:

We need 100 more rarity labels to fill these gaps, but as of right now I think we'll just be getting the one between rare and very rare, which I think is more important for the community more now.


So have we now come to a decision that the poll should have the dog tag tier, moonswirl tier, and sunjewel tier as options? Maybe with a few options for between those tiers, one higher, and one lower? Something like:

>new tier above the sunjewel
>5 nons/sunjewel tier
>between 4-5 nons
>4 nons/moonswirl tier
>between 3-4 nons
>3 nons/dog tag tier

[The Last Raven]

I really don’t think we should give an option for above the sunjewel. The skelebun isn’t that rare yet. It just recently turned OMGSR. I like the other options you gave though.

[ElementalInsanity]

I really don’t think we should give an option for above the sunjewel. The skelebun isn’t that rare yet. It just recently turned OMGSR. I like the other options you gave though.

I have to agree. I don’t think above or below is necessary. Most of my offers or ones I’ve seen have been moonswirl or sunjewel tier tbh. I would say just the three tiers would be enough.
They were for the last poll, and I really don’t feel we need to do a split or new tier for this.

[myth;]

The three tiers with the gaps between? Or would that be too much of a 'vote waste'?

And do we want to have a 'I don't know but I want to vote' option? Or will that be too wasteful as well?

[ElementalInsanity]

The three tiers with the gaps between? Or would that be too much of a 'vote waste'?

And do we want to have a 'I don't know but I want to vote' option? Or will that be too wasteful as well?

Sorry, I’m not quite sure what you mean by that first sentence? =)

And I think it was agreed on that we should keep that ‘I don’t know’ option for a few different arguments I heard. If it ends up getting a significant amount of votes that override the other choices I would say we should reconsider then.

[myth;]

The three tiers with the gaps between? Or would that be too much of a 'vote waste'?

And do we want to have a 'I don't know but I want to vote' option? Or will that be too wasteful as well?

Sorry, I’m not quite sure what you mean by that first sentence? =)

And I think it was agreed on that we should keep that ‘I don’t know’ option for a few different arguments I heard. If it ends up getting a significant amount of votes that override the other choices I would say we should reconsider then.

Ah sorry about that, I was asking if you meant we keep the three tiers and the gaps between them, so there's 5 options. ^^'

[ElementalInsanity]

Ah sorry about that, I was asking if you meant we keep the three tiers and the gaps between them, so there's 5 options. ^^'

Oh ok, lol. I don’t feel it’s necessary really. Skelebuns never seem to go for the inbetween like the peach. I think just the three tier options are the best? No need to add a new tier.

[EmberzTale]

Ah sorry about that, I was asking if you meant we keep the three tiers and the gaps between them, so there's 5 options. ^^'

Oh ok, lol. I don’t feel it’s necessary really. Skelebuns never seem to go for the inbetween like the peach. I think just the three tier options are the best? No need to add a new tier.

I agree with just the three options