The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Strawberry_dreams]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92126572&userid=603163&signature=PJWMm6ZDG6iYy1t71ITcpA

Should I?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92125989&userid=603163&signature=_Oyinn90vm-NiEPdSqz_2w

What about this one?

[Vanish]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92114865&userid=603163&signature=WIEaAhPZRQpCW8eaBXyn_A

Is this overpay? I heard the PPS goes for 2-3MA’s and mine is definitely worth more than that

Yes currently the PPS is going for 2-3 MA'S ! ( Its original worth based on rarity is 3-5 09' rares, but the pet is very well liked, such as the malk shima which is also fetching 2-3 MA's apparently )

I got some bids on my good/ice pps, which ones best?
yikes
Bid 1
2 wl rare (1 -2009, 1 -1010) 2 wl vr storepets (2012
-
Bid 2
1 wl vr (2009), 1 wl r (2012)
-
Bid 3
10 wl R (6 -2010, 1 -2013, 3 -2015), 7 wl UC (2013)+ 13 wl items)
-
Bid 4
2 wl rare (2009), 1 wl vr (2009) c$180
-
Thanks!

I gave someone some information on the Good PPS a few hours ago( they were asking for value information on it since they saw someone paying 2 MA's for it), let me go fetch that for you!:

The good PPS is a low october which should go for 3-5 09' rares. -snip *talking about someones bid* snip-. This pet has only turned VR in 2013 / not scarce. The pet is cute though so people are tending to overpay so they can get the pet (as it happens in auctions)

So i'd personally recommend the first bid as 2012 storepets are worth & demanded at a high advent+
( Please ask the bidder if they know this ^! )

Would this be fair, I'm not good at items
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92125738&userid=611416&signature=Ay7GB0jx_bv_Vz2JP4XEOg

I think both items are 2014 (one is from the summer event then and the other seems to be easter.)

Unfair to you! Their pets do not add up to a 2014 uncommon (what each of your items are worth).

Is this a fair trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92119833&userid=797978&signature=gK1U-x7MuaadazJgEMKfKA

Unfair to them! . . . Despite both pets being uncommon, their dog is much older (=more valuable to a lot of people).
(( I can DM you a thread going in-depth with trading(rarities, years, demand, etc) if you'd like!! ))

quick, is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92125797&userid=838986&signature=Xm0Zb1vxSO3a1kA4LgQOFA

You're overpaying by a lot! Just the 09' VR red-crayon dog and 09' VR malk wolf is enough!;

The Blue Scarf Dog, due to being a low october, is worth 3-5 09' Rares (according to this list) !

I know nothing about item worths. Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92126158&userid=796216&signature=UB43T7fdli30xLQk6X3CSw

Very unfair to them! Your oldest item is the 'Opulent Fae Gown' from the 2019 Fae Mischief Event !
( I value all of your items at a 2019 common per - excluding the horns & crown which i value at an uncommon )

Is this fair??

Massive overpay on your side! I only see high septembers / the Red X PPS at 350-400c$ ! ! !

- - - - - - - - -
hope this helps!

[Blue_Aussie]

This?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92126736&userid=768234&signature=HiAenp4YcX5ReAn5FsIXug

[Panda-Love-100]

Is this trade fair to both sides? If not, what would we need to add to make it fair?

[ToxikxWolf77]

This? Thank you in advance! <3

[atreyu]

Any help with this is greatly appreciated! ^^

[skinnedfur]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92127046&userid=847408&signature=_Lwb4n33PdOFaCUcdNagkw

opinions?

[popcorn1925]

Edit!!!
TRADE 1
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92110284&userid=232847&signature=91508ufRdenrRq2o8Jpfhg

TRADE 2
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92127553&userid=232847&signature=hgBShB3UBr829DZNlnDnPw

I really want to accept this, but I am not good at knowing what my pets are worth lol. Could someone please help me out!

[rosemary♥]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92127564&userid=623277&signature=V9t83ug_eG8KKdwL5tV16Q

[This Is Halloween]

is this fair for their banana