The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Frankina]

Would this be fair? Im thinking this is slightly unfair to me but I can't be too sure. Help?

They're actually overpaying. Your pet(if the white scarf dog) is on the lowest tier of the advent list. Theyre offering 6th and 7th tiers, I believe. So it's unfair to them.

I disagree.
That is the Scarf PPS, a low September List.
(can be mistaken with the Grown White Scarf Dog)
It's unfair to the PPS by a low advent and 2 '09 rares.

[floofy tyler]

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... T_qclchIWQ

I believe the gaps on the Sept. List is a tier 1 advent. That would make it unfair to you. Get a second opinion just to be sure.

Second opinions?
Thanks to Quackers

[Alerian]

Would this be fair? Im thinking this is slightly unfair to me but I can't be too sure. Help?

They're actually overpaying. Your pet(if the white scarf dog) is on the lowest tier of the advent list. Theyre offering 6th and 7th tiers, I believe. So it's unfair to them.

I disagree.
That is the Scarf PPS, a low September List.
(can be mistaken with the Grown White Scarf Dog)
It's unfair to the PPS by a low advent and 2 '09 rares.

Certainly that is not a Grown white scarf as shown it has it's rarity.
and thank you for your opinion! I was thinking the same but I couldn't figure what I needed to add

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Would this be fair? Im thinking this is slightly unfair to me but I can't be too sure. Help?

They're actually overpaying. Your pet(if the white scarf dog) is on the lowest tier of the advent list. Theyre offering 6th and 7th tiers, I believe. So it's unfair to them.

thats a scarf pps, not a grown scarf dog ^^
the scarf pps is worth three mid advents so they would need another mid advent to be fair

[lumos .]

They're actually overpaying. Your pet(if the white scarf dog) is on the lowest tier of the advent list. Theyre offering 6th and 7th tiers, I believe. So it's unfair to them.[/quote]

I disagree.
That is the Scarf PPS, a low September List.
(can be mistaken with the Grown White Scarf Dog)
It's unfair to the PPS by a low advent and 2 '09 rares.

[/quote]

Certainly that is not a Grown white scarf as shown it has it's rarity.
and thank you for your opinion! I was thinking the same but I couldn't figure what I needed to add

That was my fault. My eyes saw it as an unknown rarity.

[NoodleSoup]

Is this fair? Thanks for any help!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jgKJqJ8AkA

[amylovescallie.]

hey guys! could you please help me out and tell me if this is fair
thank you
xx

Unfair to you.

Is this trade fair?

Unfair to them

how much would they need to add?
xx

[Waki]

Please help! What should be added taken away? This is very important XD thankyou sooooooooo much for ANYONE that helps! <3

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Y_QOxLb9Yg

[Foxtress]

A non is worth two sorbets, right?
&
How many sorbets would be fair for a July PPS?

[lightningthewolf127]

A non is worth two sorbets, right?
&
How many sorbets would be fair for a July PPS?

3 actually so i beleive 6