The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[Ethulai]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24186493&userid=76663&signature=ZxX24VRpqO-8ETYkcb4ciA
Is this considered fair, or..? If I were to knock off the pure white dog on my side, what would I have to do to the other to make it fair? c:

No, no, no!

Two of your pets are from the Advent list (Ice Blue Swirl & Blue-spotted) and the other is extremely popular (White Feb)

The Rares List Guide <--- read this thread

Hold onto your doggies until you get a much better offer!

[Resin]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24215812&userid=241831&signature=lEdjJQUg4tb7K2vwbEfCGw

Is this fair or would I have to add more to my side?

[Iwein]

What do they have to take off to make it fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z8qvrUoJFA

Still waiting guys....

[Ethulai]

What do they have to take off to make it fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z8qvrUoJFA

Still waiting guys....

C$ trades are tricky. Your items cost $7

Here is some public opinion

I would say it is extremely unfair to your trading partner, but at the same time I would rather keep my valuable C$ items and build them up until I could get, like the above post said, a '10 rare for C$7-10, or a common '09 rare for C$20-25.

[e-sheep]

Can someone tell me, if those three beach event flowers are worth the same?

Thanks for any help

[Delete_Please]

Pure curiousity. Is this fair?

No, not at all. In fact, extremely unfair.

Your re-release is a Zodiac dog from January 2010. That litter is quite popular and all of them are rare.

The PPS dog and bunny are from the same year, but much, much later.

I would have cancelled this trade in a heartbeat

Any chance of a second opinion please?
So far I've been given several contradictory opinions on both the dog and the previous trade the dog was in; I'm curious whether I can get a consensus on anything.
(Not intended to cause offence to anyone, please do not take it that way)

[Ethulai]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24215812&userid=241831&signature=lEdjJQUg4tb7K2vwbEfCGw

Is this fair or would I have to add more to my side?

According to the 'How much is this pet worth?' thread

Penguin PPS Malk horse = 2 - 3 mid '09 rares so that trade is fair

[Ethulai]

Pure curiousity. Is this fair?

No, not at all. In fact, extremely unfair.

Your re-release is a Zodiac dog from January 2010. That litter is quite popular and all of them are rare.

The PPS dog and bunny are from the same year, but much, much later.

I would have cancelled this trade in a heartbeat

Any chance of a second opinion please?
So far I've been given several contradictory opinions on both the dog and the previous trade the dog was in; I'm curious whether I can get a consensus on anything.
(Not intended to cause offence to anyone, please do not take it that way)

No offense taken, but this post might be of interest to you

[Pippi]

Fair? :3

[Ethulai]

Fair? :3

Quite unfair to top