I don't think so, don't even remember what it was. I joined in January 2009, so it was either one of the monthlies from that month or more likely a sitting cat (or warrior cat, as they were know as back then). I'm a cat person, so I can totally see myself going for the cats first, but I have no idea to be fair.
But as far as I can tell, this dude is the oldest pet I adopted on my own and that I still own though ^.^