The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Mirko best hero]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93452726&userid=1009060&signature=IgbWYvaBIL_m2IbBukwC2g

There’s like an 8 years difference so I thought it was unfair but to just double check. Was this unfair or fair?

yeah this would have been extremely unfair for the rat

[PaperRose]

Thanks for all the help with the last trade and I was hoping to get some help with these ones. Doing an auction and wanted to know how fair these are. I think I'm getting better at understanding fair trades but I can't seem to find anywhere how much a very rare is worth in rares if it's not on an official list somewhere. Thanks and have a great day everyone!
Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3

[Vlad Dracula III]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93429514&userid=669307&signature=fiPwBi1LthEsOyUQTLVPIg

Would this be a fair trade?

[Issy03]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93452726&userid=1009060&signature=IgbWYvaBIL_m2IbBukwC2g

There’s like an 8 years difference so I thought it was unfair but to just double check. Was this unfair or fair?

yeah this would have been extremely unfair for the rat

Thanks

[mossi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93452726&userid=1009060&signature=IgbWYvaBIL_m2IbBukwC2g

There’s like an 8 years difference so I thought it was unfair but to just double check. Was this unfair or fair?

not a fair trade unless the person offering the rat values species HIGHLY above date, which some people do! (personally i dont)

[Issy03]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93452726&userid=1009060&signature=IgbWYvaBIL_m2IbBukwC2g

There’s like an 8 years difference so I thought it was unfair but to just double check. Was this unfair or fair?

not a fair trade unless the person offering the rat values species HIGHLY above date, which some people do! (personally i dont)

Oh the rats mine >~< they offered for my rat
I don’t value species over other species

[kmaybell]

Thanks for all the help with the last trade and I was hoping to get some help with these ones. Doing an auction and wanted to know how fair these are. I think I'm getting better at understanding fair trades but I can't seem to find anywhere how much a very rare is worth in rares if it's not on an official list somewhere. Thanks and have a great day everyone!
Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3

Hi! so right off the bat 2&3 are unfair to you. Each 2012 store is worth 1 mid advent/MA (those are 8 '09 rares each). I wouldn't consider the first bid that good either but at least its not as bad the way the others are. Angel advent is .25 nons (3-4 mas) and the other rares add up to another MA worth. That means for the first bid their side is worth 4-5 mas and your side is worth 7mas (a .5 non pet is 6-7 mas) so again this one isn't great either and I wouldn't take it but its not the worst.

[Friendlyflyer]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93452499&userid=64178&signature=rYSpPDDqNaJUuk2KJM-mpg

Is this fair? If not, how can I make it fair for both?

Thank you!

[Stranger Things]

Hello! I got THIS trade, the joker bun for bulk 09’ rares and a few ma’s. Everything they added as far as I am aware, adds up to the worth of a non. If I’m wrong someone correct me please:)

But my main question is, how easy would the bun be to trade down? I’m very interested in this trade, so any help is appreciated thank you!

[mossi]

Hey! This is for an auction and I wanna know if im totally under and should be adding more please (:

Thanks! Heres the trade: trades/viewtrade.php?id=93452964&userid=859868&signature=o7Itfo8yM6bSDHvtUA8y-w