The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[gravy]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102502851&userid=896413&signature=9tjENGz49m88ZklhjBFWYg

Please someone help, is this fair?

[Greyfire]

I just received this trade and would love an opinion or two on it if possible! Fast replies would be much appreciated! <3

Side note: The carousel house is NOT on my Wishlist and I am not interested in it at all, but I am still willing to consider the trade depending on the demand of the horse for trades afterward.

[Cerberussi]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102504665&userid=870953&signature=5SouoHHYqeBDkNVrNO_Juw

is this a fair bid for my auction?

[Botanically]

Hi! Is this trade for my eros item fair? I got it from the Lost and Found and I'm not really sure what its worth. Thank you! c:

[luckydraw]

Hi, is this fair for both of us? I’m keen to get the skeleton cat but I’m not sure it’s fair for the malk dragon, and they want me to add to my side because they feel their cat is worth more. If someone could help me figure out if the base trade is fair I could go from there adding things to my side if necessary.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102506834&userid=816125&signature=9nKV9vcQK13zFoL5Uex6Vg

Thank you in advance!

[dollface,]

x is this fair?

[chwommiecwoo]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102507072&userid=33481&signature=kKtVz-NvSscMqIoTMqNhnw

My gut says that 3x 2011 UCs and 1x 2010 UC are worth more than 1x 2012 R and 1x 2014 UC but I would like to verify if that is true or not.

[OMGit`sKairi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102507072&userid=33481&signature=kKtVz-NvSscMqIoTMqNhnw

My gut says that 3x 2011 UCs and 1x 2010 UC are worth more than 1x 2012 R and 1x 2014 UC but I would like to verify if that is true or not.

Unfair to you. If you use the 2UC:1R ratio, the PPS dog and Malk cat equal their 2010R dog, but the rest of their side doesn't even cover the two remaining uncommons on your side, let alone the 2010R horse.

[chwommiecwoo]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102507072&userid=33481&signature=kKtVz-NvSscMqIoTMqNhnw

My gut says that 3x 2011 UCs and 1x 2010 UC are worth more than 1x 2012 R and 1x 2014 UC but I would like to verify if that is true or not.

Unfair to you. If you use the 2UC:1R ratio, the PPS dog and Malk cat equal their 2010R dog, but the rest of their side doesn't even cover the two remaining uncommons on your side, let alone the 2010R horse.

That's what I thought. Thanks for your help!

[OMGit`sKairi]

Hi! Is this trade for my eros item fair? I got it from the Lost and Found and I'm not really sure what its worth. Thank you! c:

Your Eros item is listed in the CS Items Guide thread as being worth a "late 09 rare or very rare, or something of similar value."
And the C$ Pricing thread lists an '09 Rare or Very Rare at C$35-55.

The items they are offering are from April 2013, Summer 2020, and Summer 2022.