The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[boston]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92054967&userid=981256&signature=zXa9X_VkSXYRK9Ll8usCeA

help? thank you to everyone who helps!

Looks fair. The unickorn is typically valued at 1 non as same with the zebra. The zebra can tend to have better demand based on my experiences with it.

[rat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92048167&userid=805631&signature=llAo7gtjjq2INigPlmFxUw

super curious! i was looking for bulk rats im just bad when it comes to trading down :'D

[bunnifical]

That's okay! With that being said and taking demand into consideration, would this trade be worth taking? Thanks so much for clearing that all up all!

x

[boston]

That's okay! With that being said and taking demand into consideration, would this trade be worth taking? Thanks so much for clearing that all up all!

x

personally i would keep the wwa. as much as i love quantity the pets on their side do not have the best demand and can be hard to trade off.

[ahirked]

That's okay! With that being said and taking demand into consideration, would this trade be worth taking? Thanks so much for clearing that all up all!

x

personally i would keep the wwa. as much as i love quantity the pets on their side do not have the best demand and can be hard to trade off.

I agree with boston!

their side:
- cake dog = 2-3 MAs, more the 2 MAs tho (see here)
- ghost cat = 3-4 09 rares (source)
- cobweb bun = 6-7 09 rares? (see brown santa cat trade for cobweb bun; previous pet worth thread puts him at 3-4 09 rares)
- emerald bwolf = 4-5 09 rares (source)
- candy cane bw = tier 5 ex-advent (= 6-7 09 rares), but note this trade here in the successful trades thread (and valuing the red x dog at 2 MAs), it would seem as though they valued it at around 2.5-3 MAs? but I'm not wholly sure about this, so I'd definitely ask for more opinions!
== roughly 4 MAs + 6-7 09 rares (just about 5 MAs) if valuing the candy cane bw at the lower end of the spectrum, otherwise pushing 6.5-7 MAs?

note:
non = 10-12 MAs or 100-150 09 rares
half non = 5-6 MA
.25 non = 2.5-3 MA
MA = 7-8 09 rares

I agree with boston however, I'm not aware of massive demand for the pets they are offering and the values seem questionable at times ;;

[kököchin]

how's this trade i sent?
is the ur fox consistently going for 1.5 nons?

also, would a blue rose be a fair 1:1 swap for a red rose with current demand? thank you for any/all responses <3

thank you @nonbinarynobody for the advice! could i have a second opinion tho?

[bunnifical]

Thank you both so much. <3

[boston]

Is this a fair offer I sent? Thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92052242&userid=641753&signature=6oq6vyn0FiD_2z-3h2ygvg

[honeycreeper]

nonswirl and clockwork bun for the ur s'mores? thanks for any help !!

honey

[boston]

Is this a fair offer I sent? Thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92052242&userid=641753&signature=6oq6vyn0FiD_2z-3h2ygvg