The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[DBD]

How is this trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SVmHtK14Hg

[elio.]

Should I accept this trade?
and also this trade?

I think I heard somewhere that, that omgsr chicken is worth 90 '09 rares I think though I might not be right.

90 09 rares is only worth about a low main list. The phoenix is worth over 2k I believe^ But I doubt anyone would have that many.
I believe it would still unfair to them assuming you value the cinnabun @ a non.

As for the second trade, they're overpaying. Your side is only worth about half of theirs. Demand wise it completely depends how you value the warriors though.

thank you, both of you!!

[sunzie]

How does this trade look?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7ArSojNM3w

The WWA (or balloon dog tier) is worth 21 mid advents or 3 blue rose tiers. So very unfair to the WWA

Thank you! I got another trade here and wondering if anyone knows if this is fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XK3QlSRZGQ

[DBD]

How is this trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SVmHtK14Hg

[Pom d'Apee]

hello c:
can anyone tell me if this trade is fair please ? '-'
thank you in advance ♥

edit:
and also is this one fair please ? '-'

I'm pretty sure the top one is unfair to you and the bottom I think is unfair too

okay thank you for your answer ♥
can i have a second opinion please ♥
and what can i do to make it fair ? '-'

[Eagle's Eye]

Hey guys.
What would I need to add to make this fair?
There are 910 pets on their side, any opinions or rough estimates are greatly appreciated!

This is a really rough estimate
Let's say their side is about 460 2014 commons
That'd be 230 2014 uncommons
Which is 57.5 2014 rares
A 2009 rare is worth 32 2014 rares. My rough estimate is that this doesn't add up to your list. (valuing a rare as four uncommons and an uncommon as 2 commons)

Or we can see it like this
Your tier 4 is worth 5-6 2009 rares
5 2009 rares=20 2009 uncommons=40 2009 commons=80 2010 commons=160 2011 commons=320 2012 commons=640 2013 commons=1280 2014 commons
More than half of their pets are from 2015 and 2016, so this is definitely quite unfair to you

[Firestar6]

Is This trade ok?

they need to add another 2016 rare for it for be fair c:

Thanks! can I get a second opinion??

[alaski]

which should i accept for my green stripe moonflight? (its common to rare quantity)

this
or
this

????

[SteampunkAngel]

How does this looks ?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dEQD5ukr6w

Very artempt to accept it

At first glance it's unfair to the cake dog. He's worth 6 mid advents so roughly 36 - 48 09 rares. The C$ is worth a fourth tier advent.

[Benzene]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XJ22uOIz3A
hi! i've already accepted this trade because i really wanted to trade down, can someone tell me if it was fair? thanks!