The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Mami_Tomoe]

Colour me stupid for asking this, buut...if the White Dragon is a UR pet then doesn't that make it worth more than the non-jewel? @___@ Maybe I just have my rarities all screwed up.

[Auzzeren]

Colour me stupid for asking this, buut...if the White Dragon is a UR pet then doesn't that make it worth more than the non-jewel? @___@ Maybe I just have my rarities all screwed up.

I don't actuall think it's a UR, because the zebra isn't a UR either, their just a bit hard to get

[Atwood]

The White Dragon is more of a special release than an UR, as UR pets are ones that were only available on Dec. 18 through the Advent Calendar. The White Dragon can potentially be gained from any Malk adoption, and its rarity has plummeted since it initially became available. I seem to recall that all the dragon eggs released on Dec. 18th grew into the white variation, the same way all the rainbow-mane foals grew into rainbow-maned adults, so they're worth nowhere near what they used to be. Unfortunately I don't know the exact value of the dragon, but it's certainly well below a Sundog - maybe around a very rare September '08 or something.

[butcherbaby]

MonniiTsuki: I think the first offer is the best, but I would be asking for more even then. I've seen someone offer a zebra before

Ah, thanks for answering! ^^

i agree....it's a nice variety of pets that you can keep or re-trade as you choose. can't hurt to try for more, it is a valuable pet.

is this a fair trade for a dog tag moon?



i was offered the non-tag & sunback + my choice of some other rares in their trades .....is this too much? too little? if not fair, how to balance it? i know the dog tag moon is quite rare.

thanks again!

I`d remove the nontag and sunback to make it fair....even then the green sorbet is still a bit much.

The dogtag is the rarest dog on the site along with jewel sun and moonswirl and the july PPS. Sunback and nontag are decent offers, altho I think I'd take out the sorbet or the halloween batdog, possibly.

anyone else want to weigh in? I am most interested in the pets on the top row, and the sunback & non-tag were from the original offer, so i won't be removing those.

next question: if i ask for *only* the pets shown on the wishlist below (in signature), what would be a reasonable amount to ask for? would say, a straight trade for all five toxics or all four sorbets be ok? all six rats & the joker bunny? two sorbets, a tribal, and three rats? that type of thing i'd like to know so if i put it upon the trade boards i could list a few "auto-accept" choices

thanks!

[haylin]

Is this fair,I have no idee when it comes for rats against dogs?

http://nl.tinypic.com/r/w1y00p/6

Pic is probaly toooooo big so I post a link

Thankyou

Person with all the pets is getting ripped off.

So what could I remove to make it more fair?

[Eucliwood]

Is this fair,I have no idee when it comes for rats against dogs?

http://nl.tinypic.com/r/w1y00p/6

Pic is probaly toooooo big so I post a link

Thankyou

Person with all the pets is getting ripped off.

So what could I remove to make it more fair?

Isnt that july rat worth like tons more than those pets.. >__>; I don't even need to ask, because it is. You're ripping them off, Hay.

[Nico]

This is a retrospective request in that the trade has already taken place.

Out of the blue, I received an offer of re-released Dogtag Moon adopted 18 Dec 09

for

They wanted my Clear Eye Galaxy adopted in July 08

While I personally value re-released pets lower than pets adopted in the month of their release, I am aware not everyone shares that view.

Even though the trade has already been made, in view of some earlier posts, I'm wondering whether I should offer her some more pets for it so that the trade is fair.

Thanks to anyone who shares an opinion.

[Twinkling Star]

What would be the best offer out of these?

viewtopic.php?f=40&t=93269

[Fiery Gatoh]

Blue Sorbet
Malk valentines cat
Malk halloween cat
Ghost cat
Black faced spider bunny
An advent lion
Light orange stripe cat

for a UR banana?

EDIT - Also this trade

Non-raccoon tail
Yellow toxic
Bright eyed galaxy
Line tribal

for a Raccoon tail. I don't think this is fair, but...y'know xD

[SkySmoke]

Blue Sorbet
Malk valentines cat
Malk halloween cat
Ghost cat
Black faced spider bunny
An advent lion
Light orange stripe cat

for a UR banana?

EDIT - Also this trade

Non-raccoon tail
Yellow toxic
Bright eyed galaxy
Line tribal

for a Raccoon tail. I don't think this is fair, but...y'know xD

I don't think the banana trade is fair

Not sure on the Raccoon tail....it sounds fair to me, but i like the toxics and galaxies more than the coon dogs...so that might be why