The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[palms]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OKhnPG3Dsw

is this fair?

[glass house]

Hello c:
Is this fair? I know it's a lot of quantity so even some rough answers would be a huge help. Thank you in advance <3

Hi there, I enjoy basic math so I decided to figure this one out haha. Alright so their side adds up to around 107 mixed '09 rares. Your side (the wolf pps), is only worth 65-76 mixed '09 rares. Their side is pretty huge overpay and it's very rare to find someone that will trade bulk rares for high lists or even has that many 09 rares to do so.

[angel furby]

hello!! can i get a few opinions on this? i've never been a big item collector so i don't really know what animal egg 1 is worth, or what it can go for! thanks <3

it depends how you value animal egg 1
it MOSTLY goes for Main List pets. and can go from the bottom of the mainlist, all the way up to nons or zebras.

your side is worth 1 non.
if you value the egg at a non, then its a fair trade.
if you don't collect items or aren't big on collecting items and Like your pet? its not fair for you.

thank you!! <3

[xolarq]

helppp

[FenFen]

How can i make this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D3YSFDj-MA

[dogtreat]

Hello c:
Is this fair? I know it's a lot of quantity so even some rough answers would be a huge help. Thank you in advance <3

Hi there, I enjoy basic math so I decided to figure this one out haha. Alright so their side adds up to around 107 mixed '09 rares. Your side (the wolf pps), is only worth 65-76 mixed '09 rares. Their side is pretty huge overpay and it's very rare to find someone that will trade bulk rares for high lists or even has that many 09 rares to do so.

not sure how you got 107,
i added up to their side being around 93.
the wolf pps = ~70-80 '09 rares

its not that big of an overpay when you're talking bulk rares instead of list trades.
personally i'd take this.
the tradee obviously knows what the dog is worth to them.

[truthbomb]

helppp

Rarity wise they’re overpaying, I’m not sure demand wise.

[Friendlypotatoe]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CYWzF7BK7Q
Is this fair? I value true dates more than non true dates so would their rare make up for the gap??? Thank you so much for any help!!

[Bella.]

Link to trade

After some second opinions, is there anything in my research that is incorrect; The rat (unless I missed it being on the list) is worth around $35-40, and one of the store pets is around $30-35. So would it be fair as one store pet for the rat, and possibly a little extra if they wanted?

Thanks in advance! <3

[Silverstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71056023&userid=904098&signature=bGZP1MLLSoH6CYWzF7BK7Q
Is this fair? I value true dates more than non true dates so would their rare make up for the gap??? Thank you so much for any help!!

true dates are worth the same as re-releases. The '16 rare doesn't make it really unfair to them, so it's still considered about fair.

How can i make this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D3YSFDj-MA

it's unfair to them. The wolf pps is worth 10 mid advents, so the cake dog, the two mid advents + 14 '09 rares are fair.