The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[CoffeeEX]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113960557&userid=881679&signature=LFc1D3040PAYonAqiBAoZw

would this be a fair plush swap?

[Muse's Epiphany]

Can I please get help with these two trades? I am completely out of touch with how to rate list pets these days. Thank you so much!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113902356&userid=50331&signature=-lmgGqMs247D6DEK02wARQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113940086&userid=50331&signature=MaI-LGWDcN3MGqKT5_l7tw

I personally wouldn’t take either trade, though the first one is fair. Your store pets have good demand and their pets (the pancakes in particular) don’t have great demand.

Thank you! Does that mean that the second trade is unfair to me?

[Otter.]

Can I please get help with these two trades? I am completely out of touch with how to rate list pets these days. Thank you so much!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113902356&userid=50331&signature=-lmgGqMs247D6DEK02wARQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113940086&userid=50331&signature=MaI-LGWDcN3MGqKT5_l7tw

I personally wouldn’t take either trade, though the first one is fair. Your store pets have good demand and their pets (the pancakes in particular) don’t have great demand.

Thank you! Does that mean that the second trade is unfair to me?

I would stick to your pets. Value wises it's over but demand wise you'll be losing alot

[Muse's Epiphany]

Can I please get help with these two trades? I am completely out of touch with how to rate list pets these days. Thank you so much!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113902356&userid=50331&signature=-lmgGqMs247D6DEK02wARQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113940086&userid=50331&signature=MaI-LGWDcN3MGqKT5_l7tw

I would stick to your pets. Value wises it's over but demand wise you'll be losing alot

Thank you!

[Mariie]

Hello
This is probably super difficult to evaluate if possible at all, but approximately what would 9764 omg so common-extremely uncommon pets from 2024-2010 be valued at? (The pets in question are located here, I know it's a longshot but maybe someone is able to help)
And also which one of these is a better offer for them
One
Two
Thank you greatly for any help 🦋

And also what about these two? Which of the 4 is the best one?
Three
Four
Thank you again 🦋

[Elwynie]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113960557&userid=881679&signature=LFc1D3040PAYonAqiBAoZw

would this be a fair plush swap?

the link is not loading ... please relink

[Muse's Epiphany]

Hello! Can somebody please help me understand the value of more recent store pets? Thank you. I'm trying to figure out whether or not this is fair.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113966131&userid=50331&signature=9LKyf15UicwTZ9QAn1EDiQ

[Snippet-1213]

Could someone help me with this trade? I have no idea item value trades/viewtrade.php?id=113967233&userid=756768&signature=3FbLohW5HSimW5OjnQuFYA

[Elwynie]

Hello! Can somebody please help me understand the value of more recent store pets? Thank you. I'm trying to figure out whether or not this is fair.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113966131&userid=50331&signature=9LKyf15UicwTZ9QAn1EDiQ

This chart should help you in the future: Guide to Store Pets
a 2023 store pet is worth 1 old rare (old rare = 2010/2011 rares)
per the 2:1 rule, 2 uncommons = 1 rare
this would be fair

[Muse's Epiphany]

Hello! Can somebody please help me understand the value of more recent store pets? Thank you. I'm trying to figure out whether or not this is fair.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113966131&userid=50331&signature=9LKyf15UicwTZ9QAn1EDiQ

This chart should help you in the future: Guide to Store Pets
a 2023 store pet is worth 1 old rare (old rare = 2010/2011 rares)
per the 2:1 rule, 2 uncommons = 1 rare
this would be fair

Thank you!