The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SmolDrago]

I am not the best with older pet rarity so any help is appreciated!
Is this trade fair?
I personally feel that rerelease and true dates are the same if that changes anything!
Thank you so much!

If TDs and RRs don't matter to you, I'd say it's a little overpay on the side with the caterpillars. All the rares they're offering are fair for the betta (09(?) Vr = 2.5 old rares) but two older EUC caterpillars is definitely overpay for the rest of the pets they want

[sweetsakura]

hi!! was thinking, was this trade fair?
thank you!

link

[ChocolateGryphon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110678755&userid=361168&signature=-jrBd2IGbXEjHlM13aygoQ
The trade got autocancelled, but I can send another one back basically
This trade is kinda confusing so I’m looking for any general help or advice for getting all the store pet lions and what my side can afford! any advice helps since I may trade multiple people ! (I wanted double lions so I could swap for the missing litter mates but generally just interested in one of each)
If my side isn’t enough, are there other pets in this group that are? accounts/viewgroup.php?userid=361168&groupid=8098471&pageStart=40

Sorry, I’m pretty clueless with store pet value !

[Wookieinmashoo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110903437&userid=245926&signature=cNwdvVWqjbp3cj9dYmseVg

Hello, could someone tell me what the pet side adds up to? Including the true dates for the malk and 08' dogs since I think they may be a little more.

I've never had someone offer me c$ before or ask for so many pets at once. Is this a fair trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110896821&userid=932459&signature=rqlv-J6CkSdKsmein7Nc-g
sorry I don't know how to make it a link 😅

Most people offer 5C$ per current year rare at minimum, there are some that do more. Based on that, no, this is not fair

Hey!
Just curious about this one!

Some people offer more for true dates pets, which the ones on the non balloon side mostly are. Based on "true dated-ness" this might be slight underpay. Typically 1 non balloon = .5 non and 5 MA = .5 non so it would be missing 2 MA to cover it (which the true dates might cover?). Someone knowing more about true dates would be able to give more info.

[Pinecous]

Hey!
Just curious about this one!

[hinata]

are these fair? thinking about accepting the first one but I just want to make sure first!
first trade
second trade

[sweetsakura]

are these fair? thinking about accepting the first one but I just want to make sure first!
first trade
second trade

I wouldn't say either are fair. the moonswirl bun is a low T3 omgsr worth around 2MA or 350c$. The banana goes for around 1 non which is 10MA or 2000c$. the rest of the pets don't seem to even it out..

the second one is beyond unfair. the omgsr pastel dog goes for around 3 nons. the other side is extremely unfair for it.

[Skitties]

Reposting in the new thread:

Hello, I'm looking for some advice on these two trades. I don't trade high value things often enough to know the worth of these offers, and bulk stuff confuses me.

Offer one

Offer two

Offer one would become mostly trade fodder, while offer two is entirely wishlist if that makes any difference.

Thank you!

[daybreak.]

Hey!
Just curious about this one!

Top is overpaying by about 2 MA per Horror's guide (top = 10 MA / bottom = nonballoon 5MA + 3 MA). However, lots of people are seeking trade-downs nowadays, and the pets on the bottom side have decent demand, so it's not a bad deal. That might make up for the value disparity.

[Karzar'ill]

I need help with this trade, UR Phoenix for a bunch of old store pets and I'm not sure if is fair.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110906158&userid=413084&signature=wP2OfpJrHU87-xuhs1uhPQ