The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[QuailWings]

Is this fair? I'm not sure what store pets are worth ^^;
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108447998&userid=660504&signature=8P1vKZczAcgI1J91LP51Qg

unfair to you
a recent's year store pet is worth a early 2011 rare-very rare, and their side isn't offering even close value.

Is this fair? I'm not sure what store pets are worth ^^;
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108447998&userid=660504&signature=8P1vKZczAcgI1J91LP51Qg

a 2023 store pet is worth a 2011 rare, which their side doesn’t add up to, so i’d say this is unfair to you.

Thank you both!

[samiam52900]

Hi, is this fair for me?
I would prefer to trade my store pets for store pets, but is this fair? Thank you!

sam

[GL1TZY]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108433463&userid=978537&signature=jxA-Q98dPKe_rTSlWuGVNg

[Synapsid]

No rares here, but wondering about these older staff pets:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108443775&userid=526141&signature=Wl2piKBmeZ5tn94OLoEB3g

[meowcent]

hi just wondering if this is fair??
also I'm hoarding the caterpillar that's why they've traded me that

but still idk if its fair. Any advice would be amazing! <3

The trade <--

[musicgurl333]

No rares here, but wondering about these older staff pets:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108443775&userid=526141&signature=Wl2piKBmeZ5tn94OLoEB3g

Staff pets do tend to have slightly higher than average demand, but the key word there is *slightly*. I'm not sure on the dates of all of the items, but without doing the math, I'm guessing this is *probably* unfair to you because of the big age gap, based on the outdated "2:1 rule" for years. However, more people moving to greater flexibility around years, with many using a "3:1 rule" where recent pets that are within 3 years and the same rarity can swap freely. Personally, I think that the added items (especially the spirit items, which seem to have a bit of demand) and EUC more than make up for the gap in years.

[Synapsid]

No rares here, but wondering about these older staff pets:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108443775&userid=526141&signature=Wl2piKBmeZ5tn94OLoEB3g

Staff pets do tend to have slightly higher than average demand, but the key word there is *slightly*. I'm not sure on the dates of all of the items, but without doing the math, I'm guessing this is *probably* unfair to you because of the big age gap, based on the outdated "2:1 rule" for years. However, more people moving to greater flexibility around years, with many using a "3:1 rule" where recent pets that are within 3 years and the same rarity can swap freely. Personally, I think that the added items (especially the spirit items, which seem to have a bit of demand) and EUC more than make up for the gap in years.

That makes a lot of sense, thank you so much!! :3

[glitter]

which bid for a patchwork is better?
- ur pps dragon
- td 4 digit ceg

[- Alice -]

can i get some help with this bid?;
bid one!

[Mr. Grizz]

Could someone please help? I do not do trades too often.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108437550&userid=29835&signature=uOJqpTsfaUwYaf4onY9mdQ