The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[OMGit`sKairi]

Is this ok? Involves C$ for a spider.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=102470308&userid=203847&signature=cHGHeLayxhWxYcYuL4E01w

Based on the C$ pricing thread a 2011 uncommon is C$7-10. In my experience some people value Malk pets higher than others, and some people value spiders lower than other species.

[flyingiraffe]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102467165&userid=822773&signature=RvVhCGrfmUN7yEBQIzZo6g

Is this fair for both sides?

[Relara]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102486006&userid=698931&signature=E8PkhIZ3DE4TIGeHPqkDGQ im bad with item trades and store pets

[CHINARIZING]

Would appreciate any thoughts on this!

[eaneul]

Have this trade. Ends up being 9 2009 rares. If an ma is 6-9 09 rares is this worth it being at the very end of the scale? I'm considering editing to pull 2-4 of the 2010s considering how old some of the 2009s are. Should I leave it and accept as is or what should be pulled to equal values?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=102483478&userid=703022&signature=Wr0XgZJxYYOkeqQ1IgxtAQ

[Kitkat2716]

I would really appreciate some help on these offers for my UR. Thank you to anyone who can help!

Trade 1
Trade 2
Trade 3
Trade 4
Trade 5
Trade 6

[KingSpinosaurus]

Is this ok?
Link

[Xeroxoe]

This trade
Any help is appreciated

[Mothmans Wife]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102464914&userid=940544&signature=2AHOQG5MEvZ40XtqppURgQ hows this?

[musicgurl333]

Have this trade. Ends up being 9 2009 rares. If an ma is 6-9 09 rares is this worth it being at the very end of the scale? I'm considering editing to pull 2-4 of the 2010s considering how old some of the 2009s are. Should I leave it and accept as is or what should be pulled to equal values?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=102483478&userid=703022&signature=Wr0XgZJxYYOkeqQ1IgxtAQ

For what it’s worth, a lot of the ‘10 rares on your side are on the low end of being rare (they turned rare much later than many other ‘10 rares). Also, one of the ‘09 dogs on your side is an extended release that was available for a long time. While it’s typically considered worth an ‘09 rare, I personally think that over values it, as it was available for much longer than any other ‘09 rares and seems to be pretty widely available ( personally I value it as a ‘10 rare).

With all of that in mind, and considering the good demand of that store pet set, I honestly think it that seems like a very reasonable trade. You could try taking off two ‘10 rares if you wanted, but there’s no way I’d suggest taking off 4.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102464914&userid=940544&signature=2AHOQG5MEvZ40XtqppURgQ hows this?

Valuing the store pets as a ‘10 rare each, and using the “2:1 rule”, it’s unfair to you by about 1 ‘10 rare (the deer doesn’t add much). However, zebras tend to have pretty low demand, so that’s definitely something to keep in mind.