The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[MCLAREN]

please may I have some help on this trade

hi! so their joker bun is worth 1 n (10-12 MA) as their horse constantly goes for 1.5-2 MA

2 Alien dogs = 2 MA,
each jabberwocky = 6 MA (in total)
goat fairy 2015 store pets= 3 MA (in total, being consistently traded for 1 ma)
= 11 MA


the joker buns demand is a little bad, probably why they add the cara horse
so it is fair!

[Dead or Alive]

Oh my this is a lot… Any help is appreciated⭐️ Thanks in advance!!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96510487&userid=911581&signature=sHQRimjmJllNfwI3gDURhA

[MCLAREN]

Is this fair at all?
Thanks a bunch!

hi! the corgis are currently going for 1 MA, as the cara horses consistently 1.5-2 MA each
They would have to add a bit to fill the gap!

[Mavi]

Is this fair at all?
Thanks a bunch!

hi! the corgis are currently going for 1 MA, as the cara horses consistently 1.5-2 MA each
They would have to add a bit to fill the gap!

Thank you so much!

[MCLAREN]

Oh my this is a lot… Any help is appreciated⭐️ Thanks in advance!!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96510487&userid=911581&signature=sHQRimjmJllNfwI3gDURhA

Hi!! Decided to calculate this for ya <3

Purple Bat dog goes for 3 MA (Your side) each MA is 8-9 09 rares, so its worth 24-27 09 rares

With that, scourge goes for 2-3 09 rares (maybe a bit more due to demand)
We have 11 ‘10 rares, adding up to 5 ‘09 rares

We have 4 ‘11 adding up too 2, ‘10 = 1 09 rare or 6 09 rares in total,
So far we have 8-9 09 rares

The 2013-2016 are outliers.

Now for the storepets;
Using this conver:
2011 = september - low main +
2012 = high advent +
2013 = ma
2014 = la
2015 = 2 '09 rares
2016 = early '09 rare
2017 = mid '09 rare
2018 = late '09 rare
2019 = early '10 rare
2020 = mid '10 rare
2021 = late '10 rare

4 09 rares for the 2019 VR dogs,
1 09 rare for the 2017 VR
5 09 rares fir the 2018 VR dogs,
4 09 rares for 2018 cat stores
13 20-21 stores equating too = 6 09 + the extra ‘10 we had earlier = 7 09 rares

That 2020 VR dog is a 2009 VR equalling to two 09 rares
The rest are outliers

As for the items, i am unsure about the item worth, so you can look at this thread for further info:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3719854

Regardless, if we add everything up it totals to:
31 09 rares > your bat dog ( 24-27 ) (if someone wants to double check my calculations, feel free too)

[RedRook]

I need help with two trades.

This one which has my 2009 rerelease doggo

And this one which is for two of my rares and a bunch of uncommons and commons

[wet rat]

was this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=96466551&userid=919651&signature=kIYTgSi6aBDQuPadvo-_PQ

pretty sur eit was i'm just wondering anyway because they explained it to me and they seem to know a lot about rares, plus i would have done it anyway ii love this pet sm,, ty for help

[Lee-Sins]

I need help with two trades.

This one which has my 2009 rerelease doggo

And this one which is for two of my rares and a bunch of uncommons and commons

The first is unfair to you;
Your dog is worth 2 ‘09 rares at minimum value, not including demand.
They would need to add at minimum a ‘09 rare. I’m not sure of what they need to add to fill the ‘10 rare gap with the outliers as mixed rarity isn’t my forte, but regardless it’s unfair to you.

Second is unfair to them due to dates. A 2012 uncommon, for example, is worth roughly fourteen or so uncommons from 2019. (I could be wrong about the math here, but an older uncommon is worth a whole lot more than newer rares/commons/uncommons).

[RedRook]

I need help with two trades.

This one which has my 2009 rerelease doggo

And this one which is for two of my rares and a bunch of uncommons and commons

The first is unfair to you;
Your dog is worth 2 ‘09 rares at minimum value, not including demand.
They would need to add at minimum a ‘09 rare. I’m not sure of what they need to add to fill the ‘10 rare gap with the outliers as mixed rarity isn’t my forte, but regardless it’s unfair to you.

Second is unfair to them due to dates. A 2012 uncommon, for example, is worth roughly fourteen or so uncommons from 2019. (I could be wrong about the math here, but an older uncommon is worth a whole lot more than newer rares/commons/uncommons).

Thanks!

[QueenYeenBean]

May I get help with this trade?
Ty
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96513331&userid=976898&signature=Z-Gw3X_3v-QcUUrjpj7RQA