The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[Tsabhira]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23963067&userid=31289&signature=H8aDtjshjORJH-naUkU7MQ

I'm thinking this is probably unfair to my trading partner, but how much should I remove to even it out? Thanks!

[Minimetoo]

What would a Green Sorbet need to add to be fair for a CE Galaxy?

[Kevinsaurus]

How much/what needs to be added to make this fair?

Thanks!

Thanks to my two answers.
What needs to be added?

And another... What needs to be added?

My brain is clogged from school and lack of sleep. xD

1) Unless I missed something, nothing on their side really compares to the value of the blue sorb. There isn't really anything you can add to it simply because it has almost no value compared to the sorb.
2) ~ 09 UR Dog

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23963067&userid=31289&signature=H8aDtjshjORJH-naUkU7MQ

I'm thinking this is probably unfair to my trading partner, but how much should I remove to even it out? Thanks!

Unless I missed some old item, which I don't believe I did, one of the later '09 rare horses is enough for all of that. The items are all rather recent and worth commons from recent years at most.

What would a Green Sorbet need to add to be fair for a CE Galaxy?

Rarity-wise at the moment, nothing. From a demand perspective and what the CEG could get in an auction and such, possibly up to around an x pps to skele pps range.

[Dakotak]

I know the Wolf PPS is low on the main list and the Red Cerberus is equal to that of a September list and the Blue rose is on the September list. So this would be a over pay on the Wolf PPS correct?


For

Mm... no I'd say that's pretty close. It looks about right to me but maybe slightly unfair to the PPS. Only by a few 09 rares though is all.

With demand it is very close.

Would it still be fair if I swapped out the water elemental cat for the fire elemental cat?

[ferncat]

Holy-....I dont know what to say..I just got this..and..well..I'm kinda speachless...so..is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yqfKru1RAg

This is still driving me crazy..I dont know if it's fair or not.

Unfair to you.. :C

[Kevinsaurus]

Would it still be fair if I swapped out the water elemental cat for the fire elemental cat?

Yes, that swap is fine, any of the malk elemental cats can be swapped for each other in general.

[lazulixi]

Holy-....I dont know what to say..I just got this..and..well..I'm kinda speachless...so..is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yqfKru1RAg

This is still driving me crazy..I dont know if it's fair or not.

Unfair to you.. :C

Ferncat is right, unfair to you.

[KioloDovahkiin]

1) Trade 1

2) Trade 2

3) Trade 3

4) Trade 4

5) Trade 5

6) Trade 6

Sorry about all the trades. But which are fair/unfair?
If unfair what needs to be added/removed?

Thanks,
~ Leroy

[Ironic Equation]

CE Galaxy + ? = Purple Toxic

[♥Sterek♥]

1) Trade 1

2) Trade 2

3) Trade 3

4) Trade 4

5) Trade 5

6) Trade 6

Sorry about all the trades. But which are fair/unfair?
If unfair what needs to be added/removed?

Thanks,
~ Leroy

Unfair to top
unfair to you
unfair to top
unfair to top
unfair to you
pretty fair.