The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Syntyche]

I'm just curious as to which of these is a more valuable offer (it doesn't matter what it's for). Person 1 was my offer in an auction, and I was told that Person 2 and Person 3's offers were better than mine. I think that's way off-base, but I want to know if I'm wrong so I can re-evaluate the value of my pets. Thanks in advance!

Person 1:
Any five dogs from this group
(Total of 5 rare dogs)

Person 2:
Malk egg, dogtag moon bunny, Christmas tree from Advent '09, green and white butterwolf from Dec '09, PPS lion cub
(Total of 1 very rare bunny, 1 unknown rarity egg, 1 uncommon tree, 1 uncommon butterwolf, and 1 uncommon lion)

Person 3:
Lava lamp PPS pup, Halloween spiderweb bunny, Easter gray-and-white bunny, fireworks PPS pup,and green camo Oct '08 dog
(Total of 1 rare dog, 2 uncommon dogs, and 2 rare bunnies)

[vejitadmc]

I'm just curious as to which of these is a more valuable offer (it doesn't matter what it's for). Person 1 was my offer in an auction, and I was told that Person 2 and Person 3's offers were better than mine. I think that's way off-base, but I want to know if I'm wrong so I can re-evaluate the value of my pets. Thanks in advance!

Person 1:
Any five dogs from this group
(Total of 5 rare dogs)

Person 2:
Malk egg, dogtag moon bunny, Christmas tree from Advent '09, green and white butterwolf from Dec '09, PPS lion cub
(Total of 1 very rare bunny, 1 unknown rarity egg, 1 uncommon tree, 1 uncommon butterwolf, and 1 uncommon lion)

Person 3:
Lava lamp PPS pup, Halloween spiderweb bunny, Easter gray-and-white bunny, fireworks PPS pup,and green camo Oct '08 dog
(Total of 1 rare dog, 2 uncommon dogs, and 2 rare bunnies)

Personally I think I would go for person 2's offer. I think its better because the pet he/she offers are harder to get, and there is at least one VR in there :3

[Syntyche]

Personally I think I would go for person 2's offer. I think its better because the pet he/she offers are harder to get, and there is at least one VR in there :3

I agree, I think Person 2's offer might be a bit better than mine. But the auction owner wouldn't even list my offer, he just said, "It's a good offer but I'm afraid the other 2 are better." I dunno, I guess it depends on what you're looking for. But my offer has to better than Person 3's, and theirs got listed. >_<

[Placid]

I think it depends on what the person who is having the auction really wants and likes. Then try and offer more of those pets so the person is more persuaded to accept your offer over others.

in the end it all depends on who offers more of what they want >.< some people just trade them away for other pets anyways

[Fake Diamond]

non-tag

for

White july pps?

Fair?

[haylin]

non-tag

for

White july pps?

Fair?

Unfair verry unfair for the pps owner.The nontag isn't that rare as the pps!

[Celestial]

non-tag

for

White july pps?

Fair?

Unfair verry unfair for the pps owner.The nontag isn't that rare as the pps!

Agree!

[Fake Diamond]

Oh ok thanks

[Celestial]

I'm just curious as to which of these is a more valuable offer (it doesn't matter what it's for). Person 1 was my offer in an auction, and I was told that Person 2 and Person 3's offers were better than mine. I think that's way off-base, but I want to know if I'm wrong so I can re-evaluate the value of my pets. Thanks in advance!

Person 1:
Any five dogs from this group
(Total of 5 rare dogs)

Person 2:
Malk egg, dogtag moon bunny, Christmas tree from Advent '09, green and white butterwolf from Dec '09, PPS lion cub
(Total of 1 very rare bunny, 1 unknown rarity egg, 1 uncommon tree, 1 uncommon butterwolf, and 1 uncommon lion)

Person 3:
Lava lamp PPS pup, Halloween spiderweb bunny, Easter gray-and-white bunny, fireworks PPS pup,and green camo Oct '08 dog
(Total of 1 rare dog, 2 uncommon dogs, and 2 rare bunnies)

Pretty sure the first is the best (:

[Corporal Levi]

Is this fair?