The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Bernie Sanders]

Is this a fair trade?
My advent puppy with the mixing bowl blanket for green sparkle dog.

[loyalwolf06]

Is this fair?
Me: Bone PPS pre-July pup (from the Advent Calender last year)
Then: Boar PPS (NOT the advent one, the original PPS one)

that sounds fair :3

Really? A December 2008 for a 2009? Though I guess the Boar PPS pets were and still are hard to come by. The both say "rare" but I'm not sure I want the Boar that badly. I like to keep my 2008 pets to trade for other 2008 pets I don't have.

[Svaler]

Is this a fair trade?
My advent puppy with the mixing bowl blanket for green sparkle dog.

Yes.

[Bernie Sanders]

Is this a fair trade?
My advent puppy with the mixing bowl blanket for green sparkle dog.

Yes.

Ok, thanks!

[loyalwolf06]

Is this a fair trade?
My advent puppy with the mixing bowl blanket for green sparkle dog.

Yes.

I wouldn't make the trade. Tess suggests only trading advents for other advents. That will probably be at least uncommon if not rare when this is all over and I'm not sure the green sparkle dog is worth it. If it's an extra though and you really want the dog, go for it.

[Cirque]

Is this fair?
Me: Bone PPS pre-July pup (from the Advent Calender last year)
Then: Boar PPS (NOT the advent one, the original PPS one)

that sounds fair :3

Really? A December 2008 for a 2009? Though I guess the Boar PPS pets were and still are hard to come by. The both say "rare" but I'm not sure I want the Boar that badly. I like to keep my 2008 pets to trade for other 2008 pets I don't have.

well the boar PPS are one of the hardest 09 PPS pets to come by, and the bone advent is a somewhat common advent, but it mostly depends how much you want to trade the advent and how much you want the boar :3

[riley.∞]

Is this fair?
Me: Bone PPS pre-July pup (from the Advent Calender last year)
Then: Boar PPS (NOT the advent one, the original PPS one)

that sounds fair :3

Really? A December 2008 for a 2009? Though I guess the Boar PPS pets were and still are hard to come by. The both say "rare" but I'm not sure I want the Boar that badly. I like to keep my 2008 pets to trade for other 2008 pets I don't have.

Loyalwolf, I'd have to agree with you on that one. No matter how much I love my boar, I know someone would never give me a Bone PPS for it! You'd be better choosing an extra few on their side.

[loyalwolf06]

Is this fair?
Me: Bone PPS pre-July pup (from the Advent Calender last year)
Then: Boar PPS (NOT the advent one, the original PPS one)

Really? A December 2008 for a 2009? Though I guess the Boar PPS pets were and still are hard to come by. The both say "rare" but I'm not sure I want the Boar that badly. I like to keep my 2008 pets to trade for other 2008 pets I don't have.

Loyalwolf, I'd have to agree with you on that one. No matter how much I love my boar, I know someone would never give me a Bone PPS for it! You'd be better choosing an extra few on their side.

What would make it fair? Adding an uncommon? An advent lion (if they were willing to give it up)? Just a common?

[riley.∞]

Probably an uncommon (yes, a lion would be suitable.)

[red october]

My Side: Snow Pup
Their Side: Elf PPS

Is this fair?