The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Shika]

Thank you both.

[Atwood]

I think that's what sublime meant - the Cake Dog is worth more than the PPS, and so it's not an even trade.

[Santa Ria]

I think that's what sublime meant - the Cake Dog is worth more than the PPS, and so it's not an even trade.

LOL -- yes I meant that the cake dog is worth more.

[tricks]

I think that's what sublime meant - the Cake Dog is worth more than the PPS, and so it's not an even trade.

LOL -- yes I meant that the cake dog is worth more.

Yep, sublime is right.

[ryka]

If I wanted an advent Fox-dog what can I trade for it?
many decline my offers just because the dog's an advent and my trades "aren't worth it"
The dog's not even that rare... >.>

[ryka]

I've offered dogs from this year with rarities like common and uncommon.
so, like 2 or 3 uncommon dogs for an advent fox-dog... is it a fair trade? if not, please explain why...

[Atwood]

The rarity ratings are extremely loosely defined, so 'uncommon' can cover a wide range of rarities. For example, the rainbow drafts are labeled 'uncommon' but are actually very easy to come by and considered effectively worthless for trading. The Fox Advent is also 'uncommon', but it's quite valuable and highly sought - basically, no number of rainbow drafts would be equal to it. Without you showing us specifically what you were offering, we can't say if your offers were fair or not.

[Diabolic]

Me: Blue Rose dog.

Them: Pink blue-eyed pointy-eared 2008 September (at least that's what I think they are called)

I'm a little vary of letting the Rose dog go in the first place, really. Not my dream dog, but I think I got it in a quite fair arm-for-arm deal...

[ryka]

hmmm well i guess i wont be able to get an advent after all...
im convinced that my trade offers arent fair T_T
i have one more question: what does it take to trade for a 2008 toxic to make it a fair trade?

[Diabolic]

hmmm well i guess i wont be able to get an advent after all...
im convinced that my trade offers arent fair T_T
i have one more question: what does it take to trade for a 2008 toxic to make it a fair trade?

A whole lot of Rare pets. From both 2009 and 2008. I would know - I just traded for one. *pets her red toxic*