The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Mami_Tomoe]

Now that the rarity has been updated and the eat me dog is "very rare", what's fair to ask for?

Hm, well you could probably get a Wood Angel and anything else from '09, but as far as '08's go I don't know if you could get any Augusts or if that would be making the eat me dog to rare.

[dozy]

"Two" Dice pony for a Green and Black Nick B-Day pet?

[Tsabhira]

I just recieved this trade and it seems kinda unfair for me, but I'd like a second opinion before I cancel (just in case it actually is a good trade)

Their side: Black October 08 rat, uncommon
Pale Advent dog w/scarf & candycane and snowflake mark on flank, uncommon
Camo Advent (? it was adopted in December) dog w/dogtag, uncommon
Easter bunny- pale w/collar & dogtag, rare
August PPS pony, rare

My side: Grinning pups blue & purple, rare
July grey butterwolf, rare
Zombie ponies, all 3, rare
Skeleton bunny, very rare
Cerberus, rare
Silver ferret pup, unknown rarity
common pets x 26 (17 are all my extra plushie rats)
uncommon pets x 6
Warrior cats x 14

[Mami_Tomoe]

I just recieved this trade and it seems kinda unfair for me, but I'd like a second opinion before I cancel (just in case it actually is a good trade)

Their side: Black October 08 rat, uncommon
Pale Advent dog w/scarf & candycane and snowflake mark on flank, uncommon
Camo Advent (? it was adopted in December) dog w/dogtag, uncommon
Easter bunny- pale w/collar & dogtag, rare
August PPS pony, rare

My side: Grinning pups blue & purple, rare
July grey butterwolf, rare
Zombie ponies, all 3, rare
Skeleton bunny, very rare
Cerberus, rare
Silver ferret pup, unknown rarity
common pets x 26 (17 are all my extra plushie rats)
uncommon pets x 6
Warrior cats x 14

That is totally unfair on their part and I would cancle faster than the other person could blink. That is ridiculus that they would ask for all that.

[Carm]

Black-eyed galaxy for glowing red PPS & green toxic rat '08
Should I offer more?

I would want different pets for my Black-Eyed Galaxy.

Then what other pets should I offer? >_>

Anyone?

[Santa Ria]

I just recieved this trade and it seems kinda unfair for me, but I'd like a second opinion before I cancel (just in case it actually is a good trade)

Their side: Black October 08 rat, uncommon
Pale Advent dog w/scarf & candycane and snowflake mark on flank, uncommon
Camo Advent (? it was adopted in December) dog w/dogtag, uncommon
Easter bunny- pale w/collar & dogtag, rare
August PPS pony, rare

My side: Grinning pups blue & purple, rare
July grey butterwolf, rare
Zombie ponies, all 3, rare
Skeleton bunny, very rare
Cerberus, rare
Silver ferret pup, unknown rarity
common pets x 26 (17 are all my extra plushie rats)
uncommon pets x 6
Warrior cats x 14

Totally unfair to you.

[Tsabhira]

Totally unfair to you.

That is totally unfair on your part and I would cancle faster than the other person could blink. That is ridiculus that they would ask for all that.

Thank you both! I had a feeling they might be trying to pull a fast one on me...

[Peaches92]

For my Yellow Sorbet:
September 08 Red X and Pink Balloon Dog

[Achi]

So, what exactly is the Red Devil PPS worth?
My Red Devil PPS for their Eat Me dog?

[Peaches92]

For my Yellow Sorbet:
September 08 Red X and Pink Balloon Dog