The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[SixthSatan]

Is this fair? I am a newbie and need help.

They are asking me for the stuff in the red boxes.. http://i37.tinypic.com/2z9br5f.jpg

Thanks

[Cottleston]

ok, is this fair? I don't think so but I'm not sure how rare the halloweens are.

Them: Spiky eared+ 1 floppy eared red halloween puppy (the ones from the candy exchange, bith the ones that have grown yet)
Me: Angel advent.

Thanks!

Not fair. An angel advent is worth more!

Thanks also would just the spiky-eared pup be worth the brown bobtail advent with the purple star?

[Midnight_Shadow18450]

Is this fair? I am a newbie and need help.

They are asking me for the stuff in the red boxes.. http://i37.tinypic.com/2z9br5f.jpg

Thanks

Those pets aren't that rare.... I don't think it's fair, but best to get another person's opinion too.

[ocelotboye]

Is this fair? I am a newbie and need help.

They are asking me for the stuff in the red boxes.. http://i37.tinypic.com/2z9br5f.jpg

Thanks

Those pets that are on his side are very common to your water cat.

[SixthSatan]

Is this fair? I am a newbie and need help.

They are asking me for the stuff in the red boxes.. http://i37.tinypic.com/2z9br5f.jpg

Thanks

Those pets that are on his side are very common to your water cat.

How rare is the water cat? Is it rarer than the 'Uncommon" the site gives it?

[ocelotboye]

Is this fair? I am a newbie and need help.

They are asking me for the stuff in the red boxes.. http://i37.tinypic.com/2z9br5f.jpg

Thanks

Those pets that are on his side are very common to your water cat.

How rare is the water cat? Is it rarer than the 'Uncommon" the site gives it?

If he says hes Giving you RARE pets, then that means that somebody is doing a newbie rip off.
Alot of people do it, saddens me.

[Drucilla]

Is this fair? I am a newbie and need help.

They are asking me for the stuff in the red boxes.. http://i37.tinypic.com/2z9br5f.jpg

Thanks

Those pets that are on his side are very common to your water cat.

How rare is the water cat? Is it rarer than the 'Uncommon" the site gives it?

The pets they are offering are certainly not RARE, as they suggested. I might considered canceling just because of that. But honestly, the trade does not appear unfair to me.

[KyoshiYan]

Just what is a new malk dragon egg worth? no one can really answer it right now x.x

[SixthSatan]

Well, I can understand the items being rare, but not the pets. Hmm.. this is a tough one. Just the fact it is wanted bad enough that they try to trick me a bit makes me want to keep it, lol

Thanks guys.

[acciobadger]

Cervas said less than a Grey Malk Dragon, so maybe a few common Octobers 08? Or a few Septembers maybe..