The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[shystru]

just got these 2 bids

which bid is better/ should I accept? I love the store pets but I'm not sure

the first on is slightly better at 3ma as the bid on the bottom is only worth 2.8-2.9 so the difference between the two is 10-20 old rares

[TooSpooky]

just got these 2 bids

which bid is better/ should I accept? I love the store pets but I'm not sure

the first on is slightly better at 3ma as the bid on the bottom is only worth 2.8-2.9 so the difference between the two is 10-20 old rares

Wouldn't it be 1-2 old rares difference?? I thought 1ma is 10 old rares?

[Kurou]

just got these 2 bids

which bid is better/ should I accept? I love the store pets but I'm not sure

the first on is slightly better at 3ma as the bid on the bottom is only worth 2.8-2.9 so the difference between the two is 10-20 old rares

Wouldn't it be 1-2 old rares difference?? I thought 1ma is 10 old rares?

Yes, it would be only 1-2 '11-'10 rares difference. (:

[shystru]

just got these 2 bids

which bid is better/ should I accept? I love the store pets but I'm not sure

the first on is slightly better at 3ma as the bid on the bottom is only worth 2.8-2.9 so the difference between the two is 10-20 old rares

Wouldn't it be 1-2 old rares difference?? I thought 1ma is 10 old rares?

oh yeah sorry about that 😅

[ACat]

Hii does this look okay? :>

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111476425&userid=85238&signature=xKcE9XGCXLfm0TxvJFu0rA

[angst]

just got these 2 bids

which bid is better/ should I accept? I love the store pets but I'm not sure

I would say the store pet offer for demand. I also have seen the 2015 litter where the lemur is from go from .5 to 1MA, making this possible .5MA overpay. That's just my opinion though! I think it's up to you!

Hii does this look okay? :>

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111476425&userid=85238&signature=xKcE9XGCXLfm0TxvJFu0rA

Looks to me like they're overpaying slightly but I could be wrong!

[Iseul]

Hey guys! Is this fair? They’re both relatively the same age, wondering about demand as well. I loveeeee the horse, just wondering if maybe it would be better for me to buy it with C$ or trade the lion.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111490842&userid=481109&signature=O7x0KbYpG6UKZqP0_sSzig

[Kurou]

Hi!! I *think* this trade offer I've sent is fair, but I just wanted to make really, really sure!
Any help would be greatly appreciated! (: Thanks a bunch in advance!
(involves a UR Bee and their worth of exactly 3 Nons in other list pets and old rares, or at least that was my intention, but I'm awful at math, so please tell me if I'm off!)

You are offering 4 OMGSRs for 1 so I would ask them for more instead. You can get a few more opinions if you want.

just want to come to quickly say this wouldnt be accurate if you're dealing with horrors list values, I wouldnt be able to give a rough estimate because im not confident with my values, but asking for more on their end would most definetly make this more unfair (depending on if this trade is already fair, please wait for another opinion before doing anything because I can't really give an educated guess atm)


while I'm here, can someone help check over this trade for me? thank you!

Thanks for your input! I sometimes really wish that would be how trading and this site's economy work, but unfortunately, that isn't the case usually. I was going off of Horror's List! (: Could I please get another feedback? (:

[angst]

@Kurou if it's helpful, I counted about 27-29 MA or a little under the 30 for the bee! But everyone counts differently so maybe I'm totally off. If I were you maybe I'd add like a few more MAs just to lock in a fair trade but it's up to you! Hopefully someone else will give their opinion.

I've also read conflicting things about the pea pps's value and what it trades for so I think personally I was getting tripped up there.

Good luck!!

[0tt3r]

hi, im unsure about this trade, if its unfair, how could i make it more fair?

^