The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Arcanine Luver]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97072298&userid=62987&signature=5wt5GLJBmEBn36yEIYqL-Q

is this fair for my TD timberwolf?

[Quackers <3]

How does this trade look?

[El.]

I would love some opinions on this bid, both sides please, anything helps

& if I could get some help with this trade please ! there is lot's of items and I want to make sure it's fair on both sides
& if someone could please explain the 2:1 rule for me or if they know a link to the large 2:1 rule chart? I know I have seen it somewhere but Ive tried using the search function and I cannot find it thank you so much for the answer!!

[/quote][/quote]

[shuichi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97072298&userid=62987&signature=5wt5GLJBmEBn36yEIYqL-Q

is this fair for my TD timberwolf?

TD doesn't have any additional value! it's all up to how much they are willing to overpay, considering TDs are preferred by most. that would be overpay by about half an MA, and they might not be happy with paying that much for a dateswap. but to answer your question, yes, any level of overpay would be fair to you. it just depends on how much you value your TD over a rerelease.

of course, some pets do have less value when rereleased (for instance, the VR warrior cats), but as far as i know this isn't the case with the timberwolf. however, please feel free to correct me if i'm mistaken.

[Gabee]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92688281&userid=943266&signature=Bg4i0g9pbT7bgSuvjTdFQw
i have had this trade sitting here for ages and i still have no clue if its fair or not... please help

[vehk]

is a basilisk fair for a yellow toxic? both are 0.5 nons, right?

1 Basilisk is 2 MAs while a Yellow Toxic ranges from .25-.5 but can fetch .5n steadily. .25n is 3-4 MAs while .5n is 5-7 MAs so one basilisk would be unfair to the Yellow toxic.

what about a basilisk + the orange nick cake dog + this blue scarf dog?

[Klaora]

I've been trying for several days now to get some advice on this, I'd be super grateful it if someone could confirm this is fair

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97038730&userid=119355&signature=OioIOjMvSsxLfEW5-EJm9g

I'm gonna help you out a little bit here -I've been hesitant to do so because I personally can't tell you if the trade is fair. (I'm really bad at knowing values of older rare pets lol )
What I can do, however, is help other people help you. I've spent over an hour compiling the list of item worths here in hopes of getting you the help you need.

How I got the values: I searched through the "How Much is This Item Worth?" thread. Anything that hasn't been mentioned on the thread, a good rule of thumb is roughly 1 uncommon from the most recent year the item came out. If I couldn't find anything in particular about it on the thread, I assume that the item isn't "notable" enough to be worth the discussion and will default to this value after combing through the item archive to find the year. I will make a note with an asterisk when I am making this assumption.

So....I'm gonna get started breaking these items down:

1-2. Love PenPen (Red and Pink) - 1 late '09 rare/VR -EACH-
3. *Chinese Lantern - early '11 Uncommon
4. *Valentines Flowers -early-mid '11 Uncommon
5. *Pink Easter Basket - early-mid '11 Uncommon
6. Sheep - '11 Uncommon
7-14. Elven Set - Highly debated and variable item. '11 Uncommon EACH *minimum*, but a full set can go for 1-2 '09 rares or even a VR for just a few pieces depending on demand. The posts I'm referencing for value might be outdated, so please seek a second opinion for this set in particular.
15. Treble Berries - I'm seeing conflicting info of '11 Uncommon - Rare all the way up to an '09 rare. I only found two posts referencing this item. It was released in 2011.
16-17. *Pumpkin Mask +Scarf - mid-late '11 Uncommon
18. *Deep Blush - early-mid '12 Uncommon
19. * White Tropical Flower - mid '12 Uncommon
20. *Big Pearl - mid '12 Uncommon
21-24. *Screwdrivers and Wrenches - 1 '12 Common each; I vaguely remember this being a free item pack that every got
25-26. *Toy/Paper Boats - '12 Uncommon each
27. *Eerie Black Contacts -'12 Uncommon - Rare; may have been a token trade-in item.
28. *Soul Cake - '12 Common to Uncommon; free Halloween item set
29. *Incense - '12 Uncommon
30. *Silver Stud - '13 Common to Uncommon
31. Nightmare - '13 Uncommon to Rare; was a banner item
32-33. Bat Armor - '13 Common to Uncommon each; was a token trade-in so it's worth a '13 Rare + as a complete set
34. Mobile - '13 Common to Uncommon each (was hard to find info since the search function brought up mobile phones lol)
35. Lunar Flower - '13 Common
36. Corrupted Dream Catcher - '13 Uncommon
37-40. Plague Doctor Set - '13 Uncommon to Rare
41. Christmas Sweater - '13 Uncommon
42. *Red Smoke Contacts - '14 Common to Uncommon
43. Skeleton Hoodie - mid-late '14 Uncommon
44. *Black Bell - Only one I could find. Likely between a '15 and '16 uncommon
45. Flurffle- '16 Uncommon to Rare
46-52. *Assorted Fish - '17 Common to Uncommon each
53-55. *Pearl + Kelp - '17 Common to Uncommon each
56. *Ship Lamp - '17 Common to Uncommon
57+ *Assorted 2021 Items - '21 Common to Uncommon each

With that, a lot of these items aren't worth more than an uncommon from the year that they were released! There's only a few that are worth a rare or higher.
That also said, finding a buyer for each of these items would be a lot of hard work.

ANYWAY, my apologies for the novel of information. I just noticed that you'd been struggling to find some info and I had some time to kill. If someone else could weigh in as to whether or not this is a fair trade for you, that would be fantastic. I REALLY hope that this helps break everything down. Feel free to compile the info however you like and have a wonderful day. ^^

[LilBowPeep]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97073016&userid=813575&signature=5r0KeYfRo_oe9PS0bnv_7Q
need help

[Halsie]

Is this trade fair?

[Black wolf Naomi]

Hii is this trade fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97069657&userid=260252&signature=t4R8s8jFSa8CD0a9iHox-Q